KALTEC

BlogApplication notes

Why does aluminium turn dark or white after washing?

Type
Application notes
Published
20 November 2026
Prepared by
Technical team
Product group
Cleaning & Surface Prep

When washed aluminium comes out stained, it is tempting to wash it again, hotter and longer, but that can deepen the mark. What actually causes it can be etching by strong alkali, smut left by alloy elements, too little inhibitor, too much heat and time, or poor rinsing and drying, and often several of these at once.

Sometimes aluminium parts come off the drying rack after washing with a surface that went in bright and came out milky, or dulled to grey or black. The marks may cover the whole part evenly, or appear only on touching faces and around holes. They look like dirt that was not washed off, yet another wash rarely helps.

Discolouration is more than looks. Etching changes dimensions and surface roughness, and leftover residue weakens adhesion in the next step, whether painting, bonding, anodising or plating. Standards on cleaning before plating note that aluminium is easily over-etched by strong alkali, so the cleaner must be chosen for the metal's chemical activity (ASTM International, 2022, 2025). And since a defect made in washing may only show in a later step, tracing its cause takes time.

Aluminium is a reactive metal, but an oxide film a few nanometres thick, formed at once in air, keeps it from corroding. This film is amphoteric, dissolving in both acid and alkali, so it is stable only near neutral, roughly between pH 4 and 9 (Deltombe & Pourbaix, 1958; Vargel, 2020). Above that range the film dissolves as aluminate, a form of aluminium that stays dissolved in water, and the bare metal then reacts directly with water (Armstrong & Braham, 1996; Deltombe & Pourbaix, 1958). That is why alkaline cleaners remove oil well but must be used on aluminium with care. White haze and dark film both begin with this film dissolving, and the cleaner's inhibitor, temperature and time, and rinsing and drying decide how far it goes.

In such cases the technical team sets up the five hypotheses below and rules them out one by one. The start is always the same: note whether the mark is white or dark and whether a clean dry cloth wipes it off, then on the same day measure the cleaner's pH, temperature and contact time and compare them with the aluminium conditions on the cleaner's technical data sheet, the TDS. That one comparison screens several hypotheses at once.

Hypothesis 1: strong alkali

The strength of the cleaner is the first thing to check, because one pH meter answers it. It shows up in tanks where concentrate is poured by eye so the dilution wanders, on lines where a little extra concentrate has been added whenever oil was slow to come off, and in washing parts covered in machining oil that need heavy degreasing. Picture this in degreasing: a bright extrusion goes into the tank, fine bubbles rise from its surface without stopping, and once it is out and dry the shine has given way to a milky haze. Rubbing with a dry cloth leaves the haze in place, and the surface feels faintly rough to the fingertip.

Those bubbles are hydrogen. Hydroxide ions in the cleaner first attack the oxide film and turn it into soluble aluminate (Armstrong & Braham, 1996; Pyun & Moon, 2000), and where the film thins, aluminium oxidises while water is reduced, giving off hydrogen gas (Pyun & Moon, 2000). A thin hydroxide layer keeps forming and dissolving on the surface, and the metal dissolves at a rate set by transport through that layer (Mysliu et al., 2023; Pyun & Moon, 2000).

The metal underneath does not dissolve evenly. The tiny crystal grains that make up the metal, their boundaries, and the areas around intermetallic particles, fine particles formed by aluminium and alloy elements, dissolve at different rates and roughen the surface on a fine scale (Koroleva et al., 1999). That roughness scatters light, so the original shine goes and the surface looks white or milky. Any aluminium hydroxide left unrinsed adds a white powder or film on top (Deltombe & Pourbaix, 1958; Vargel, 2020).

Checking starts at the tank. Fine bubbles rising steadily from aluminium parts mean the metal is dissolving. Measure the cleaner's pH every shift with a calibrated meter and compare it with the aluminium range on the TDS. To put a number on the etch, weigh a coupon, a small test piece cut from the same material, before and after washing and compare the loss. If a white haze stays after wiping and the surface feels rough, the metal itself has been etched.

If the pH is above range, correct the dilution first and meter the concentrate instead of pouring it by eye. If etching persists within range, consider an inhibited cleaner made for aluminium, or a milder alkaline or neutral cleaner with a lower pH (ASTM International, 2022, 2025). An etched surface cannot be washed back, so for parts where appearance matters, settle the conditions on coupons before running production.

Hypothesis 2: alloy smut

This is the hypothesis when the problem is a grey or black film rather than a white haze. It appears in alkaline washing or etching of copper-rich 2000-series alloys, high-silicon cast alloys and recycled aluminium of varied make-up. Say that of all the parts through one tank, only the cast housings come out dull grey, and a white glove drawn across them picks up black powder. Extrusions through the same tank are fine.

Aluminium in service is not the pure metal but an alloy carrying elements such as copper, iron, silicon and manganese. These are either dissolved in the aluminium matrix or scattered as intermetallic particles (Koroleva et al., 1999; Vargel, 2020). Alkali dissolves aluminium quickly but these elements poorly, so the aluminium leaves and the rest stays on the surface as a grey or black film. This film is called smut (Koroleva et al., 1999; Mysliu et al., 2023).

In copper-bearing alloys the effect shows clearly. In studies of aluminium-copper alloys corroded in sodium hydroxide, aluminium passed into solution while copper concentrated just below the metal surface and then stayed as copper nanoparticles inside the hydrated alumina layer (Liu et al., 2006, 2008). Among iron-bearing particles, those without silicon dissolve faster than the matrix and drop out, while those with silicon dissolve more slowly and tend to remain (Koroleva et al., 1999). Such fine metal particles absorb light and make the surface look dark, and the longer the etch, the more alloy elements gather where the metal meets the oxide layer (Mysliu et al., 2023).

A single white cloth gives the quickest answer. If rubbing picks up grey or black powder, it is smut, unlike a white haze that does not wipe off. Next, compare alloys. If only copper-rich alloys or high-silicon castings go dark in the same tank, alloy elements are the cause. Check the alloy designation and composition on the mill certificate, and match when the material changed against when the darkening began.

The shortest route to less smut is less etching, so lower the conditions under hypotheses 1 and 4 first. If etching is a necessary part of the process, follow it with an acid step, called desmutting, to strip the residual elements and the alkaline film. The acid step after alkaline cleaning also neutralises the remaining alkaline film (ASTM International, 2022, 2025). The right acid and strength depend on the alloy, so set separate conditions for high-silicon cast alloys and agree them with the supplier.

Hypothesis 3: low inhibitor

Suspect the inhibitor when pH is within range but dull and sound areas come out patched together on the same part. It shows up in plants that wash steel and aluminium in one tank, where a cleaner chosen for steel is also used on aluminium, and in tanks topped up with caustic soda or alkaline concentrate alone whenever cleaning power drops. Think of a line that washes steel brackets and aluminium covers in one tank and tops it up with caustic soda alone whenever cleaning power drops. All is well just after a fresh make-up, but with each top-up, dull patches spread further across the covers.

Some alkaline cleaners for aluminium carry a silicate such as sodium metasilicate as an inhibitor. The silicate forms a thin aluminium silicate film on the surface that keeps hydroxide ions off the oxide, which is why such cleaners are classed as non-etching (ASTM International, 2022). Research on corrosion inhibition of aluminium alloys in alkaline solution has also treated silicate as an effective inhibitor (Daufin et al., 1977).

This protection holds only while there is enough silicate. In a cleaner with little silicate to begin with, in a strong alkaline cleaner made for steel, or in a tank topped up with alkali alone so that the silicate share has fallen, the film does not form evenly. Etching as in hypothesis 1 starts where the film is missing, so dull and bright areas sit side by side on one part. Conversely, too much silicate or too little rinsing can leave the silicate film itself as a white residue (ASTM International, 2022).

Begin by asking whether the cleaner was made for aluminium at all. The TDS and the safety data sheet, the SDS, state whether it suits aluminium and whether it contains an inhibitor. Then open the top-up log and see whether alkaline concentrate or caustic soda has been added on its own. If total alkalinity, measured by titration, adding acid drop by drop, is normal while etching has grown, the inhibitor share rather than the alkali may have fallen.

Any tank that washes aluminium should run an inhibited cleaner made for aluminium, topped up with the same cleaner, not alkali alone. If steel and aluminium must share a tank, choose the cleaner for the more vulnerable metal, aluminium. If painting or bonding follows, confirm with the supplier that the silicate film will not hurt adhesion, and consider a silicate-free inhibitor if needed (ASTM International, 2022).

Hypothesis 4: too hot, too long

When pH and inhibitor are right but marks appear only on some days, look at temperature and time. It shows up after the wash temperature has been raised because oil was slow to come off, after the line has been slowed so parts stay longer in the tank, and on equipment with a long transfer between wash and rinse. A lunchtime conveyor stop makes it easy to picture. When the line restarts, only the row of hangers caught between the wash and rinse tanks comes out with white marks along the edges and lower ends.

The general rule that reactions speed up with temperature applies here as well: the dissolution of the oxide film and of aluminium both run faster when hot (Armstrong & Braham, 1996; Vargel, 2020). The longer the contact with alkali, the more the surface oxide layer grows and the more metal dissolves (Mysliu et al., 2023). That is why, with the same cleaner, a hotter wash or a longer stay in the tank makes hypotheses 1 and 2 worse together.

What is easy to miss is the time after the part leaves the tank. While hot cleaner waits on the part for the rinse, evaporation can concentrate what is left on the surface, and etching and residue can start at edges and where liquid pools. The hydrogen-forming reaction can also raise alkalinity on the spot, so an etch, once started, can speed up where it is (Moon & Pyun, 1997; Pyun & Moon, 2000).

Temperature has to be read as measured, not as set. Log the tank temperature both near the heater and away from it, and time the immersion and the transfer to the rinse separately. See also whether defects cluster after stoppages, at shift start or just after the tank has been heated. If they do, time and temperature are more likely than the cleaner.

It is safer to start low and work up. Begin at the low end of the cleaner maker's recommended temperature and time, and settle on the least that still cleans. When oil is slow to come off, look at agitation or spray pressure before raising both temperature and time. Keep the transfer from wash to rinse short, and set a rule that parts wait in the rinse tank whenever the line stops.

Hypothesis 5: poor rinse and dry

Look at rinsing and drying when parts are clean straight after washing but stained some time later. It shows up on lines where rinse water is rarely changed, on parts with many holes and gaps, where parts are stacked or packed still wet, and in seasons when parts move from a cool store into warm, humid rooms. It goes like this: a few days after shipment, the customer calls to say that a box of parts which passed final inspection was opened to find every touching face spread with white stains.

When rinsing falls short, leftover cleaner dries and leaves alkaline salts and silicate as a white film (ASTM International, 2022, 2025). The remaining alkali keeps attacking the oxide film as it dries, so a film that wiped off at first can turn into an etch mark that does not. The same can happen in the rinse itself when the rinse water has built up alkali or is hard.

Drying can cause similar trouble. When wet parts are stacked or packed, water trapped in gaps without airflow reacts with aluminium over time and leaves water stains (Aluminum Association, 2009). When cold parts move into warm, humid air and the surface falls below the dew point, moisture condenses and seeps between parts by capillary action (Aluminum Association, 2009). What forms is hydrated aluminium oxide, which shows as white stains or, as the film thickens, as darker patches (Deltombe & Pourbaix, 1958; Vargel, 2020).

Where and when the marks formed are the strongest clues. Marks on touching faces, in holes and gaps, or along drip lines point to rinsing or drying. Measuring the pH and conductivity of the final rinse at regular intervals shows whether alkali is building up. Log temperature and humidity in storage and compare the dew point with part temperature (Aluminum Association, 2009); if parts were clean straight after washing but stained after storage or shipping, treat drying and storage as the cause.

The answer lies in leaving no water or cleaner on the surface. Rinse in at least two stages, and keep clean water flowing into the final rinse so alkali does not build up. After rinsing, dry with hot air or an air blow, water in the gaps included, before stacking or packing. Keep storage away from doors with large temperature swings, and let cold parts reach room temperature before unpacking (Aluminum Association, 2009). A light water stain stops growing once fully dry, but a deep one needs the surface treated again.

Testing the hypotheses

Five hypotheses do not call for five separate investigations. Rule them out one at a time, starting with what can be seen and measured quickly.

The first step is colour and the wipe. Black powder on a white cloth points to smut, hypothesis 2; a white haze that stays points to etching, hypotheses 1, 3 and 4; and a white film that wipes off points to residue, hypothesis 5. Then note when the marks appeared. Straight after washing points first to the wash conditions; after storage or shipping, to drying and storage.

Next come the numbers. If the cleaner's pH and concentration are above the TDS range, that is hypothesis 1, so correct the dilution first. If they are within range but dull and bright areas mix on one part and the top-up log shows alkali alone, treat hypothesis 3 as the main cause; if marks cluster on certain days or after stoppages, hypothesis 4. If only one alloy goes dark, it is hypothesis 2.

If that still does not settle it, run a control test. Take two coupons of the same alloy, put one in freshly made cleaner and one in the cleaner now in use at the same temperature for the same time, rinse and dry both, and compare weight loss and appearance side by side. If only the in-use cleaner etches, the bath has changed, so look at hypothesis 1 or 3. If both etch, look at the choice of cleaner itself or at temperature and time, hypothesis 1 or 4. If the coupons are clean straight after washing and stain only after storage, it is hypothesis 5.

Once the cause is found and fixed, the last step is to confirm it in production. It is done only when the marks are gone from several production runs after the fix, weight loss on coupons under the same conditions has come down, and adhesion failures no longer appear in the next step.

One more thing to remember: the hypotheses often overlap. A tank short of inhibitor run hot brings hypotheses 1, 3 and 4 at once, and hypothesis 2 follows on copper alloys. In such cases change one thing at a time and compare before and after on coupons of the same alloy, so it is clear which step worked.

Limits and cautions

Control ranges differ by cleaner and alloy, so numbers follow the cleaner's TDS and the maker's recommended range. Acid cleaners, cleaners containing fluorides, galvanic corrosion from contact with other metals, and marks on anodised or conversion-coated surfaces work by other mechanisms and cannot be judged by the hypotheses above. For costly parts, strict appearance standards, or overlapping hypotheses that will not narrow down, send coupons and measurement records to the cleaner supplier or a surface-treatment specialist for analysis.

Safety matters too. Alkaline cleaners can burn eyes and skin (NIOSH, n.d.), so when measuring or topping up, check the SDS and wear safety glasses, chemical-resistant gloves and protective clothing. Aluminium gives off hydrogen as it dissolves (Pyun & Moon, 2000), and hydrogen is flammable, so keep the tank area ventilated and away from flames.

Sources

  1. Aluminum Association. (2009). Guidelines for minimizing water staining of aluminum (TR3, 5th ed.). https://www.aluminum.org/sites/default/files/2021-11/WaterStainingGuidelines.pdf
  2. Armstrong, R. D., & Braham, V. J. (1996). The mechanism of aluminium corrosion in alkaline solutions. Corrosion Science, 38(9), 1463–1471. https://doi.org/10.1016/0010-938X(96)00037-6
  3. ASTM International. (2022). ASTM B253-11(2022), Standard guide for preparation of aluminum alloys for electroplating. https://store.astm.org/b0253-11r22.html
  4. ASTM International. (2025). ASTM B322-99(2025), Standard guide for cleaning metals prior to electroplating. https://store.astm.org/b0322-99r25.html
  5. Daufin, G., Labre, J. P., & Pagetti, J. (1977). Corrosion inhibition of an aluminium-silicon-magnesium alloy in alkaline media. Corrosion Science, 17(11), 901–912. https://doi.org/10.1016/0010-938X(77)90096-8
  6. Deltombe, E., & Pourbaix, M. (1958). The electrochemical behavior of aluminum: Potential pH diagram of the system Al-H2O at 25 C. Corrosion, 14(11), 16–20. https://doi.org/10.5006/0010-9312-14.11.16
  7. Koroleva, E. V., Thompson, G. E., Hollrigl, G., & Bloeck, M. (1999). Surface morphological changes of aluminium alloys in alkaline solution: Effect of second phase material. Corrosion Science, 41(8), 1475–1495. https://doi.org/10.1016/S0010-938X(98)00188-7
  8. Liu, Y., Arenas, M. A., Garcia-Vergara, S. J., Hashimoto, T., Skeldon, P., Thompson, G. E., Habazaki, H., Bailey, P., & Noakes, T. C. Q. (2008). Behaviour of copper during alkaline corrosion of Al–Cu alloys. Corrosion Science, 50(5), 1475–1480. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.corsci.2008.01.021
  9. Liu, Y., Arenas, M. A., Skeldon, P., Thompson, G. E., Habazaki, H., Shimizu, K., Bailey, P., & Noakes, T. C. Q. (2006). Generation of copper nanoparticles during alkaline etching of an Al–30at.%Cu alloy. Corrosion Science, 48(8), 1874–1884. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.corsci.2005.07.011
  10. Moon, S.-M., & Pyun, S.-I. (1997). The corrosion of pure aluminium during cathodic polarization in aqueous solutions. Corrosion Science, 39(2), 399–408. https://doi.org/10.1016/S0010-938X(97)83354-9
  11. Mysliu, E., Storli, K. S., Kjørsvik, E., Lunder, O., & Erbe, A. (2023). Recycled aluminium alloys and their models: Role and behaviour of alloying elements during alkaline etching. Journal of The Electrochemical Society, 170(1), 011503. https://doi.org/10.1149/1945-7111/acb38a
  12. National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health [NIOSH]. (n.d.). NIOSH pocket guide to chemical hazards: Sodium hydroxide. https://www.cdc.gov/niosh/npg/npgd0565.html
  13. Pyun, S.-I., & Moon, S.-M. (2000). Corrosion mechanism of pure aluminium in aqueous alkaline solution. Journal of Solid State Electrochemistry, 4(5), 267–272. https://doi.org/10.1007/s100080050203
  14. Vargel, C. (2020). Corrosion of aluminium (2nd ed.). Elsevier. https://shop.elsevier.com/books/corrosion-of-aluminium/vargel/978-0-08-099925-8

Product and site consultation

Leave your company, site and the product groups in use. Our engineer will get in touch to go through your site conditions and concerns. Materials, equipment, operating conditions and downstream steps show what should change and what can stay. If nothing needs to change, we will say so.

Contact us
After you contact us
  1. 01
    Site setup

    We confirm process conditions and needs first.

  2. 02
    Spec design

    We set the product spec and selection criteria.

  3. 03
    Comparison

    We compare matching candidates and propose.

  4. 04
    Tailored supply

    We supply on time and manage the stock.

  5. 05
    Site check

    We visit, check conditions of use and record.

  6. 06
    Use management

    We track use and change cycles to catch issues.

  7. 07
    Regular analysis

    We analyze the records and send a yearly report.