KALTEC

BlogApplication notes

Why are my gears noisy and showing surface damage?

Type
Application notes
Published
20 November 2026
Prepared by
Technical team
Product group
Equipment/Service Lubricants

Changing the oil is the usual response to a noisy gearbox, but noise usually means the flanks are already damaged and the mesh is disturbed, so new oil alone may leave the cause in place. What actually damages the flanks can be a thin oil film, weak extreme-pressure protection, particles and water, heavy or uneven load, or spreading micropitting, and these often advance together.

Sometimes a gear unit starts to hum in a way it never did, and vibration readings creep up. Through the inspection cover the flanks show a polished band, a grey stain or small craters, and fresh oil does little to quieten it. The noise is the result of an uneven mesh, and behind it is whatever changed the flanks.

A gearbox usually sits in the middle of a machine carrying its power, so when the gears stop, the line stops. Damage first shows as noise and vibration, and left alone it goes on to flaking flanks or broken teeth. The international standard ISO 10825-1 names gear tooth damage as wear, scuffing, fatigue damage such as pitting and micropitting, and fracture (ISO, 2022). Naming the damage the same way is the first step to finding its cause.

The basic source of gear noise is transmission error. An ideal gear pair turns its output evenly when its input turns evenly. In practice, profile errors, tooth deflection and surface damage make the output run slightly ahead or behind at each mesh, and that unevenness excites vibration heard as noise (Mark, 1978). Lubricant protects the flanks in two ways. A thin film between the teeth that stiffens under pressure, the elastohydrodynamic film, keeps the metal apart (Hamrock & Dowson, 1977), and when the film gets too thin, additives build a protective layer on the flanks (Spikes, 2004). Grades and minimum performance of industrial gear oils are set by standards such as ANSI/AGMA 9005 (AGMA, 2016).

In such cases the technical team sets up the five hypotheses below and rules them out one by one. The start is always the same: before opening the gearbox, draw an oil sample and measure viscosity, water, particles and wear metals, read the running temperature and load records alongside, then photograph the flanks and classify the damage in standard terms.

Hypothesis 1: thin oil film

The film thins when viscosity is low, temperature is high or there is too little oil. It shows up in slow, heavily loaded gear units, in machines that start and stop often and in gearboxes with poor airflow in summer. One example is a unit filled at its last change with a grade one step lower in viscosity, because that was what the store had. When summer comes the casing is too hot to touch, and through the cover the tips and roots show a polished band where the machining marks have gone.

The film thickness between meshing teeth is set mostly by the oil's viscosity and the speed at which the surfaces enter the contact, and it is much less sensitive to load. The film thickness equation shows the film growing as viscosity and speed rise (Hamrock & Dowson, 1977). The catch is that viscosity depends strongly on temperature. As oil temperature rises, viscosity falls and the film thins, and wear, scuffing, micropitting and pitting all increase (Höhn & Michaelis, 2004).

Whether the film is enough is judged by film thickness divided by the combined roughness of the two flanks, the specific film thickness. When it is small, roughness peaks touch directly in mixed lubrication and the flanks wear away bit by bit (ISO, 2018). Low speed, heavy load and frequent starts and stops are the conditions that thin the film most, and the same happens when a lower viscosity grade than the design called for goes in or cooling has worsened (AGMA, 2016; Höhn & Michaelis, 2004).

Three things need looking at: the flanks, the temperature and the oil. On the flanks, polishing that erases the machining marks, or an even band of wear, shows first where sliding is high, at the tip and root (ISO, 2022). Log the oil temperature in service against the range set by the design or the maker, and watch for changes in summer or after a rise in load. Check the level on the sight glass with the unit stopped: too little oil leaves the teeth poorly wetted, and too much churns and heats it. Compare kinematic viscosity at 40 °C with new oil to see whether another oil got in or the grade changed, and read iron and similar wear metals rising steadily from sample to sample as a sign of ongoing mixed lubrication (ASTM International, 2024).

Take the viscosity grade from the gear maker's recommendation first; if there is none, use the selection basis in a standard such as AGMA 9005 or a film calculation (AGMA, 2016). If the oil runs above its range, put the cooler, flow and oil level right first, and only then consider one grade higher or an oil whose viscosity changes less with temperature. If mixing with another oil is confirmed, flush and refill.

Hypothesis 2: weak EP protection

In gears with high load and sliding there comes a moment when the film alone cannot hold. It tends to happen during running-in of new gears, after a sudden rise in load from a process change, or after a switch to another oil. Load on a gear unit goes up to raise output, and that same week the mesh sounds rougher and score lines in the sliding direction appear near the tips.

Scuffing is damage in which the film and the protective layer fail together, so the two flanks weld for an instant and tear apart. Where load and sliding speed are high, the contact temperature spikes, and above a certain level the film can no longer hold (Dyson, 1975). The result is rough score marks in the sliding direction, and the damage spreads fast (Dyson, 1975; ISO, 2022).

Extreme-pressure and anti-wear additives prevent this. These sulfur- and phosphorus-bearing components react with the metal surface under frictional heat and form a reaction film that shears easily, which stops the metals welding (Spikes, 2004). The film is worn off and rebuilt in use, so protection lapses when the additive is used up or the oil is too weak for the load. The scuffing resistance of gear oils is rated in the FZG test, which raises the load on test gears in stages and finds the stage at which the flanks start to score (ASTM International, 2026).

Scuffing is recognised first by the look of the flanks: rough streaks and torn patches in the sliding direction near the tip or root, while the pitch line stays fairly clean (ISO, 2022). Match the time the damage appeared with running-in, load increases and oil changes. In oil analysis, compare additive elements such as phosphorus and sulfur with new oil to see whether they have dropped sharply, and check the FZG rating of the oil in use from its product data (ASTM International, 2026).

If the oil's scuffing rating falls short of the running load, change to a higher-rated oil. Use an antiscuff oil, an EP oil as defined in AGMA 9005, for heavily loaded gears, and compare grades by FZG result (AGMA, 2016; ASTM International, 2026). Raise the load in stages during running-in, and do not mix oils with different additive chemistries when changing oil. A thicker film also lowers scuffing risk, so apply the temperature control from hypothesis 1 as well (Höhn & Michaelis, 2004).

Hypothesis 3: particles and water

Particles in the oil come in from outside or are made by the gears themselves, and water seeps in or condenses inside the casing. Typical places are dusty sites, where machines are washed down with water, where day and night temperature swings form dew inside the casing, and in gearboxes with worn breathers and seals. Drain oil from a gear unit in a dusty place such as a cement plant and it comes out cloudy, with iron fines bristling on the magnetic plug.

When hard particles are drawn into the contact, those larger than the film scratch or dent the flanks (Nikas, 2010). Stress concentrates at the rim of a dent, fatigue cracks start there first, and rolling contact fatigue life falls (Sayles & Ioannides, 1988). The debris returns to the oil and causes more damage, closing a loop (Nikas, 2010).

Water also shortens fatigue life. In roller bearing tests, fatigue life fell as the water content of the oil rose (Cantley, 1977). Water can wash out or break down additives, and it forms rust that becomes more abrasive particles. Gearbox breathers, seals, wash-down water and condensation are the usual entry routes.

The oil sample tells a lot. Record particle counts as an ISO 4406 code and follow the trend (ISO, 2021). Ferrography shows particle shape and size and separates cutting, fatigue and oxide types; with a baseline set for each machine, more and larger particles signal a developing fault (ASTM International, 2024). If the oil is cloudy or water collects at the bottom, measure water content. On the flanks look for fine scratches in the sliding direction, small dents and small pits starting around them (ISO, 2022).

Set a target cleanliness code and compare each sample with it (ISO, 2021). If it is exceeded, fit a desiccant breather, check the seals, and on circulating systems tighten the filter rating or run a portable filter cart. For water, close the entry route first, then change the oil or remove the water. When changing oil, clear the sludge at the bottom and the debris on the magnetic plug as well.

Hypothesis 4: heavy or uneven load

When load exceeds the design or crowds one end of the face, the teeth do not last however good the oil. This happens on machines with heavy start-up shock, on lines where a process change raised the torque, and in gearboxes knocked out of alignment by shaft deflection or bearing wear. Consider a unit whose bearings were replaced without the shafts being realigned: months later a row of small craters forms at one end of the pinion face only, and a regular throb creeps into the sound.

Rolling, pressing load repeated countless times leaves small craters in the flank. That is pitting: rolling contact fatigue grows cracks at or just below the surface until pieces fall out (Olver, 2005). Fatigue life depends strongly on contact stress, so the same gear pits early when the real load exceeds the design. That is why the gear rating standard ISO 6336-1 accounts separately for variation in external load through the application factor, for dynamic load in the mesh through the dynamic factor, and for load distribution across the face width (ISO, 2019).

Misalignment crowds the load towards one end of the face, raising the stress there, and the pits form there first (ISO, 2019). As pits multiply the profile changes, and transmission error and noise rise (Mark, 1978).

Where the pits sit is the first clue. If they crowd one end of the face, suspect misalignment first; if they spread evenly across it, suspect overall overload (ISO, 2019, 2022). Apply a marking compound to see whether the contact pattern spreads evenly across the face, and use motor current or torque logs to match peak load and the frequency of shocks with when the process or equipment changed. In the vibration trend, watch whether the mesh frequency, the number of teeth times shaft speed, and the sidebands on either side of it grow. Sidebands appear when a particular tooth or shaft has a fault (Mark, 1978).

Where misalignment shows, correct the shaft alignment, bearing clearance and housing mounting first. If the real load exceeds the design, recalculate the rating with the gear maker, and reduce start-up shock with methods such as soft starting (ISO, 2019). On the lubrication side, keeping the film thick and the oil clean helps fatigue life (Höhn & Michaelis, 2004; Sayles & Ioannides, 1988). Changing the oil alone, though, cannot cure mechanical overload.

Hypothesis 5: micropitting

Long running on a thin film spreads another kind of fatigue over the flanks. It is seen on gears with rough flanks, on units running slowly under heavy load for long periods and in gearboxes whose oil stays hot. On a unit photographed at the same spot at every inspection, a dull grey band below the pitch line towards the root grows a little wider from one photo to the next.

Micropitting is damage made of countless very shallow, tiny fatigue pits, which to the eye look like a grey stain or a frosted pattern on the flank (Errichello, 2012; ISO, 2022). In mixed lubrication, where roughness peaks touch, each peak takes high stress over and over in short cycles, and cracks start and spread just below the surface (Errichello, 2012; Oila & Bull, 2005). In twin-disc tests, load had the largest effect on the start of micropitting, and speed and slide-to-roll ratio the largest effects on its growth (Oila & Bull, 2005).

The calculation method ISO/TS 6336-22 judges micropitting risk by whether the specific film thickness at each point on the flank falls below a permissible value set for each oil. The same gear thus has different limits with different oils, and the limit comes from the oil's micropitting test result (ISO, 2018). Micropitting alters the profile, raising transmission error, and as it advances it becomes a starting point for larger pits (Errichello, 2012; Mark, 1978).

Having found a grey band, first scratch it with a fingernail. Micropitting is a dull grey band that does not rub off, often below the pitch line towards the root (Errichello, 2012). Photograph the same spot under the same light at intervals to see whether the grey area grows, and look in the oil for fine fatigue-type wear particles and a slow rise in iron (ASTM International, 2024).

The remedy centres on the film. Correct oil temperature and viscosity towards a thicker film (Höhn & Michaelis, 2004; ISO, 2018), and when changing oil choose a gear oil with a micropitting test result (ISO, 2018). Finishing that lowers flank roughness also reduces the risk (Errichello, 2012; ISO, 2018). If the grey area does not grow, keep watching; if it grows or larger pits appear in it, review the pitting measures under hypothesis 4 as well.

Testing the hypotheses

Testing five hypotheses does not start with stripping the gearbox. Rule them out one at a time, beginning with what can be seen without opening it, such as the oil and the records.

The first step is to note when the sound changed and match it against oil changes, load changes, season and maintenance. Then compare an oil sample's viscosity, water, ISO 4406 cleanliness, wear metals and additive elements with new oil (ASTM International, 2024; ISO, 2021). Temperature above its range puts hypothesis 1 first, and a rise in load puts hypotheses 2 and 4 first (Höhn & Michaelis, 2004; ISO, 2019); poor cleanliness or high water points to hypothesis 3.

When it is time to look at the flanks, photograph them and classify the damage in ISO 10825-1 terms. Polish and wear bands point to the film, streaks in the sliding direction to scuffing, fine scratches and dents to contamination, grey stains to micropitting and craters to pitting (ISO, 2022). Note where the damage sits too: at one end of the face, suspect alignment first; at tip and root, sliding and film; near the pitch line, fatigue (ISO, 2019, 2022).

When the evidence is split, set up a control. Put the oil analysis and vibration trend beside those of a neighbouring unit of the same type, and it becomes clear whether one machine has a problem or the oil or duty as a whole. Use wear particle shape to see whether cutting, fatigue or oxidation dominates (ASTM International, 2024), and changes at the mesh frequency and its sidebands to judge whether the damage is progressing (Mark, 1978). The job is done only when both trends stop after the fix.

One hypothesis can also invite another. A thin film brings micropitting and scuffing together, contaminant particles bring pitting forward, and micropitting eventually leads to pitting (Errichello, 2012; Höhn & Michaelis, 2004; Sayles & Ioannides, 1988). When several signs appear together, fix first what measurement confirms directly, such as temperature, viscosity, cleanliness and alignment, then watch how the damage progresses to narrow down the rest.

Limits and cautions

The gear maker's instructions come first on oil grade and change interval (AGMA, 2016). Unlike enclosed industrial gearboxes with steel gears, worm, hypoid, open, plastic and grease-lubricated gears differ in mechanism and oil selection and are judged separately (AGMA, 2016; ISO, 2022). The FZG test runs on a spur gear rig, and oils with high EP additive levels, of API GL-4 and GL-5 class, exceed the rig's maximum load and cannot be told apart (ASTM International, 2026). Gear noise can also come from damaged bearings, so if the flanks look sound, check the bearings as well.

If a tooth has broken, vibration has risen sharply in a short time or pits are spreading fast, stop the machine and have the gear maker or a rotating-machinery specialist inspect it. Isolate and lock out power before opening a gearbox. When handling hot oil and additives, check the product's safety data sheet, the SDS, and wear protective gloves and eye protection.

Sources

  1. American Gear Manufacturers Association [AGMA]. (2016). ANSI/AGMA 9005-F16, Industrial gear lubrication. https://webstore.ansi.org/standards/agma/ansiagma9005f16
  2. ASTM International. (2024). ASTM D7690-24, Standard practice for microscopic characterization of particles from in-service lubricants by analytical ferrography. https://store.astm.org/d7690-24.html
  3. ASTM International. (2026). ASTM D5182-26, Standard test method for evaluating the scuffing load capacity of oils (FZG A/8.3/90 method). https://store.astm.org/d5182-26.html
  4. Cantley, R. E. (1977). The effect of water in lubricating oil on bearing fatigue life. ASLE Transactions, 20(3), 244–248. https://doi.org/10.1080/05698197708982838
  5. Dyson, A. (1975). Scuffing: A review. Tribology International, 8(2), 77–87. https://doi.org/10.1016/0301-679X(75)90056-0
  6. Errichello, R. L. (2012, November/December). Morphology of micropitting. Gear Technology, 74–81. https://www.geartechnology.com/morphology-of-micropitting
  7. Hamrock, B. J., & Dowson, D. (1977). Isothermal elastohydrodynamic lubrication of point contacts: Part III, Fully flooded results. Journal of Lubrication Technology, 99(2), 264–275. https://doi.org/10.1115/1.3453074
  8. Höhn, B.-R., & Michaelis, K. (2004). Influence of oil temperature on gear failures. Tribology International, 37(2), 103–109. https://doi.org/10.1016/S0301-679X(03)00047-1
  9. International Organization for Standardization [ISO]. (2018). ISO/TS 6336-22:2018, Calculation of load capacity of spur and helical gears, Part 22: Calculation of micropitting load capacity. https://www.iso.org/standard/73528.html
  10. International Organization for Standardization [ISO]. (2019). ISO 6336-1:2019, Calculation of load capacity of spur and helical gears, Part 1: Basic principles, introduction and general influence factors. https://webstore.ansi.org/preview-pages/ISO/preview_ISO+6336-1-2019.pdf
  11. International Organization for Standardization [ISO]. (2021). ISO 4406:2021, Hydraulic fluid power, Fluids, Method for coding the level of contamination by solid particles. https://www.iso.org/standard/79716.html
  12. International Organization for Standardization [ISO]. (2022). ISO 10825-1:2022, Gears, Wear and damage to gear teeth, Part 1: Nomenclature and characteristics. https://www.iso.org/standard/78719.html
  13. Mark, W. D. (1978). Analysis of the vibratory excitation of gear systems: Basic theory. The Journal of the Acoustical Society of America, 63(5), 1409–1430. https://doi.org/10.1121/1.381876
  14. Nikas, G. K. (2010). A state-of-the-art review on the effects of particulate contamination and related topics in machine-element contacts. Proceedings of the Institution of Mechanical Engineers, Part J: Journal of Engineering Tribology, 224(5), 453–479. https://doi.org/10.1243/13506501JET752
  15. Oila, A., & Bull, S. J. (2005). Assessment of the factors influencing micropitting in rolling/sliding contacts. Wear, 258(10), 1510–1524. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.wear.2004.10.012
  16. Olver, A. V. (2005). The mechanism of rolling contact fatigue: An update. Proceedings of the Institution of Mechanical Engineers, Part J: Journal of Engineering Tribology, 219(5), 313–330. https://doi.org/10.1243/135065005X9808
  17. Sayles, R. S., & Ioannides, E. (1988). Debris damage in rolling bearings and its effects on fatigue life. Journal of Tribology, 110(1), 26–31. https://doi.org/10.1115/1.3261569
  18. Spikes, H. (2004). The history and mechanisms of ZDDP. Tribology Letters, 17, 469–489. https://doi.org/10.1023/B:TRIL.0000044495.26882.b5

Product and site consultation

Leave your company, site and the product groups in use. Our engineer will get in touch to go through your site conditions and concerns. Materials, equipment, operating conditions and downstream steps show what should change and what can stay. If nothing needs to change, we will say so.

Contact us
After you contact us
  1. 01
    Site setup

    We confirm process conditions and needs first.

  2. 02
    Spec design

    We set the product spec and selection criteria.

  3. 03
    Comparison

    We compare matching candidates and propose.

  4. 04
    Tailored supply

    We supply on time and manage the stock.

  5. 05
    Site check

    We visit, check conditions of use and record.

  6. 06
    Use management

    We track use and change cycles to catch issues.

  7. 07
    Regular analysis

    We analyze the records and send a yearly report.