BlogApplication notes
Why has my grease softened and run out?
- Type
- Application notes
- Published
- 20 November 2026
- Prepared by
- Technical team
- Product group
- Greases
Greasing more often and more heavily is the usual response to grease running out, but an overfilled bearing churns its grease into heat and pressure and can push even more of it out. What actually thins grease or makes it run out can be mixing with an incompatible grease, water getting in, base oil separating, heat and over-greasing, or thickener fibres cut by shear, and two or more of these can overlap.
Sometimes a trail of grease appears below a motor's bearing housing, and a few days after it is wiped off it has spread again. Adding more grease quietens things for a while, then even more runs out. Pressed between the fingers it is thinner than fresh grease, and in some spots there is only clear oil instead. When grease will not stay in place, something in the grease itself or in the way it goes in has changed.
Run-out bears directly on maintenance cost and machine life. Once grease gets past the seals, less is left in the bearing, the oil in what remains is used up faster, and the lubricating film thins. Leaked grease fouls floors and products, and in a motor it can reach the windings and cause other faults. Over time bearing life shortens and downtime and replacement costs rise (Lugt, 2013).
Grease is a semi-solid in which a thickener of fibres or particles holds the base oil, the oil that actually lubricates, like a net. It is the base oil that wets the contact; the thickener is the container that keeps that oil in place. Bearings take grease instead of oil because this consistency keeps it inside the bearing and helps seal out dirt and water (Lugt, 2009). Consistency is measured by cone penetration: a standard cone is dropped onto the grease and the depth it sinks is read in tenths of a millimetre, so a larger number means a softer grease. The worked penetration, taken after 60 double strokes, sets the NLGI consistency grade, and penetrations of 85 to 475 span NLGI 6 to 000 (ASTM International, 2021b). So the sense that grease has gone soft can be turned into a number, the change in penetration before and after use.
In such cases the technical team sets up the five hypotheses below and rules them out one by one. The first check never changes: set the grease that ran out beside fresh grease of the same product, compare colour, smell, feel, water droplets and pooled oil, photograph them, and search the maintenance records for any recent change of grease, supplier or greasing practice.
Hypothesis 1: mixed greases
When run-out starts after a grease change, look at mixing first. Typical moments are just after a switch of supplier or product, when an outside maintenance contractor brings its own grease, when one grease gun makes the rounds of several machines, and when a centralised lubrication system is changed over to a new grease. Suppose the grease supplier changed on price, and the fitter filled bearings still holding the old grease with the new one as usual. Nothing happens for the first few days; a few weeks later, streaky grease is pushing out of every gap in the housings.
Greases differ inside. Thickeners alone include lithium soap, complex soaps, polyurea and clay, and base oils and additives vary from grease to grease. When two are mixed, the residual grease can interfere with how the new grease's thickener structure forms, an additive from one can drop out of solution in the other and stop working, and some additives thin the grease when they meet certain thickeners (Aikin, 2023). Base oils may not mix either: silicone oils do not blend well with most base oils, nor do some polyalkylene glycols with mineral oils or synthetic hydrocarbons (Aikin, 2023).
In a test that blended pairs from ten greases with different thickeners, every grease was incompatible with at least one other, and the most common result was substantial softening. Aluminium complex, calcium complex, clay and polyurea greases were the ones most often incompatible (Gebarin, n.d.). Even thickeners of the same family can clash through their base oils or additives, so compatibility charts built on thickener names alone can be incomplete or misleading (Aikin, 2023; Gebarin, n.d.). Composition alone does not predict compatibility, which is why the standard judges it by testing the blend itself (ASTM International, 2024b).
Start by lining up the dates. If the day the grease type, supplier or lot changed sits close to the day run-out began, this hypothesis moves to the front. Purged grease with a colour between the two, streaks, or a separate layer of oil points to mixing (Gebarin, n.d.). As a quick test, blend the two greases half and half, measure the 60-stroke worked penetration and compare it with each grease alone; a blend much softer than both suggests incompatibility (Aikin, 2023). Formally, ASTM D6185 compares a blend's dropping point, penetration after 100,000 strokes of prolonged working and storage stability at elevated temperature with those of the two neat greases, and a failure on any one means incompatible (ASTM International, 2024b).
From now on, assume any two greases are incompatible when changing over, and do not mix them until a test says otherwise. Wipe the old grease out completely wherever parts can be reached (Aikin, 2023). If the change must happen in service, use up as much old grease as possible, pump the new grease in slowly until the purged grease changes colour and consistency, and raise the amount for the first two intervals to push out what remains (Gebarin, n.d.). Empty a centralised system of the old grease and run it in manual mode until new grease appears at every point, then return it to automatic (Aikin, 2023). After the change, collect purged grease and check its consistency and oil separation before going back to the normal interval (Gebarin, n.d.).
Hypothesis 2: water ingress
On lines washed down often, at points splashed with coolant or process water, on outdoor equipment in the rain, and where day and night temperatures swing enough for dew to form inside the housing, water is a prime suspect. Imagine a conveyor hosed down at high pressure at the end of every shift. The jet sweeps past the bearing housing seals again and again, and the next morning milky, clouded grease is beading under the housing.
Water works its way between the thickener fibres and disrupts the bonds between them. In a study of commercial greases, lithium, lithium complex and polyurea greases softened as they took up water, losing together their zero-shear viscosity, the stiffness at rest, their yield stress, the force needed to start flow, and their storage modulus, the spring-back after a push. Calcium sulfonate greases went the other way and became stiffer after absorbing a good deal of water (Cyriac et al., 2016). The same water gives different results in different greases, so at wet points the choice of thickener decides the outcome.
Grease softened by water is pushed out more easily as the bearing turns, and the water left behind invites rust and aids oxidation, cutting bearing life (Lugt, 2013). How readily water washes grease out can be compared at 38 °C and 79 °C with the ASTM D1264 water washout test, but that value does not replace evaluation in the field (ASTM International, 2016).
Appearance is the quickest clue. Purged grease that is milky, shows droplets or swells into foam when rubbed has taken in water. Walk the area for pressure washing, coolant spray, outdoor exposure and condensation, and match the records to see whether run-out rises the day after washing. A dab of grease on a hot metal plate that crackles is a field check some use, but confirm the water content by laboratory analysis.
Where water is to blame, close its way in first. Keep wash nozzles from aiming straight at seals, and check that seals and covers are undamaged. At wet points, shorten the relubrication interval so that water-laden grease is pushed out by fresh grease (Holdmeyer, 2022). If it keeps recurring, reselect the grease on a thickener that holds its consistency when wet and on water washout results, running the compatibility check from hypothesis 1 before any switch (ASTM International, 2024b; Cyriac et al., 2016).
Hypothesis 3: oil separation
Oil separation shows itself when what runs out is clear oil rather than grease. It tends to arise at hot points, on machines with strong vibration, on fast parts where centrifugal force is high and in pails stored for a long time, and it stands out more in greases with low-viscosity oil or little thickener. A pail that has spent months on a store shelf is opened to show a thin film of clear oil on top. Under the bearings of a vibrating screen filled with the same grease there are oil stains instead of lumps of grease, and the grease left inside the housing crumbles between the fingers.
The thickener net holds base oil the way a sponge does, by capillary force, the pull of fine gaps on a liquid. Grease wets the contact by giving up this oil a little at a time, which is called bleeding. How fast it bleeds depends on oil content, how well oil and thickener cling to each other, how open and elastic the net is, and oil viscosity. So greases with low-viscosity oil, little thickener or an open net lose oil more easily (Hogenberk et al., 2025).
Heat softens grease and lowers oil viscosity, so bleeding speeds up. Pressure, centrifugal force and vibration squeeze oil out of the net. Even in storage, the grease's own weight and time are enough to draw oil to the surface, and that is the oil found pooled on top of a pail (ASTM International, 2024a). When bleeding goes too far, oil alone runs off and fouls the floor, while the grease left behind dries and hardens, and lubrication fails (Lugt, 2013).
Checking starts with what ran out. Clear oil instead of grease, with the remaining grease firm or crumbly, means oil separation. Check opened pails for oil pooling on top as well. Separation in storage is measured by ASTM D1742, a method not suited to greases softer than NLGI 1 (ASTM International, 2024a). To compare supplied greases, use ASTM D6184: the grease sits in a conical sieve, at 100 °C for 30 hours unless specified otherwise, and the oil that drains is weighed (ASTM International, 2022b).
Do not stir oil pooled in storage back in with a stick; wipe it off and smooth the surface so less of it meets the air. Keep pails closed in a cool, shaded place and use the oldest first. If separation is heavy in service, bring down the temperature and vibration at that point first, then consider a grease with lower separation at heat or a higher base-oil viscosity (ASTM International, 2022b; Hogenberk et al., 2025). Results from the two tests are not interchangeable, so compare only values from the same test (ASTM International, 2022b).
Hypothesis 4: heat and over-greasing
Heat comes from outside and from within. Equipment near dryers or other heat sources, and fast-running motors, take in a lot of outside heat, while points greased by a set number of gun strokes on a schedule, without measuring the amount, make heat of their own. The motor on an exhaust fan beside a drying oven is one such place. Every week, by the maintenance schedule, each fitting gets several strokes of the grease gun; afterwards the housing runs hot for a while, and darkened grease pushes out round the edge of the shield.
As temperature rises, the thickener net loosens so the grease softens, and the base oil reacts with oxygen. Oxidation first uses up the antioxidants blended into the grease; once they are nearly gone it speeds up sharply, acids and other oxidation products form, and weight is lost as light fractions evaporate. Oxidation rate rises exponentially with temperature, and a widely used rule of thumb holds that every 10 to 15 °C rise halves grease life. Which way heat ageing moves a grease depends on the thickener: at 150 °C, lithium greases have been reported to soften while polyurea greases hardened (Schneidhofer et al., 2025). In a 30-day ageing test at 130 °C, most of the change in properties came in the first 10 days, when most of the base oil evaporated (Dokter & Osara, 2025).
The heat from within comes from over-greasing. With too much grease, the rolling elements, the bearing's balls or rollers, have no free space and must plough through it, and this churning makes heat and pressure. When the pressure beats the shield, grease is forced out, and dirt gets in through the same gap (Holdmeyer, 2022). The shop-floor complaint that the more goes in, the more comes out usually describes this state. The dropping point, the temperature at which grease melts and drips, is a static value for identifying grease type and for quality control, not a sign that grease can run that hot (ASTM International, 2022a).
Two measurements cover it, temperature and amount. Log housing temperature regularly with a non-contact thermometer: a rise just after greasing that lingers is the pattern of over-greasing, while a clear fall after greasing means the bearing had been short of grease. Weigh what one stroke of the grease gun delivers so the amount actually put in is known; one third to one half of the bearing's free space is a common guide (Holdmeyer, 2022). If the purged grease is dark brown or black and smells burnt or sour, suspect oxidation as well (Schneidhofer et al., 2025).
If the running temperature is above the range recommended in the maker's technical data, consider a grease suited to it, chosen on high-temperature life data rather than dropping point (ASTM International, 2022a). Shorten relubrication intervals at hot points so oxidised grease is pushed out early. Where over-greasing is the problem, set the amount by weight and keep any relief port open. Without one, take the grease fitting out for 5 to 10 minutes while the bearing runs after greasing so the excess can escape, and never force grease into a sealed bearing (Holdmeyer, 2022).
Hypothesis 5: shear breakdown
When none of the earlier signs is present but grease thins at certain points only, look last at shear. These are places where grease is worked without rest: high-speed shafts, machines with strong vibration, and parts that oscillate. Of two shafts greased with the same product on the same interval, only the bearing on the one that vibrates more lets grease run out. Colour and smell are close to fresh grease, yet rubbed between the fingers it spreads thin, without the stringy pull it had.
Fibrous thickeners such as lithium, lithium complex and polyurea build a net of long, tangled fibres that traps the oil. When grease is dragged between rolling elements and worked, the fibres snap into shorter pieces and the tangle loosens, so the grease grows steadily softer. Softening is fast at first and slows with time, because shorter fibres are harder to break further (Zhou, 2018). This mechanical degradation does not reverse, so stopping the machine does not bring back the original consistency, and it runs faster with higher speed, stronger vibration and continuous churning (Lugt, 2013). The two hours of the standard roll stability test may still fall in a transient period, so that result alone says little about long-term mechanical stability (Gurt & Khonsari, 2025).
The difference in penetration between used and fresh grease is what reveals this hypothesis. Measure grease taken from the housing against fresh grease from the same pail under the same conditions, and use the small-cone methods in ASTM D217 when the sample is small (ASTM International, 2021b). To compare the shear stability of supplied greases, look at the change in penetration after prolonged working or at ASTM D1831 roll stability results (ASTM International, 2021a, 2024b).
Snapped fibres do not join up again, so greasing the same product more often will not be enough. Consider a grease with higher shear stability, one whose penetration changes less after prolonged working or roll testing, and look at roll stability run longer than the standard two hours (Gurt & Khonsari, 2025). Where vibration is high, correct alignment and balance first. Until then, shorten the relubrication interval so the broken-down grease is pushed out by fresh grease, and log the consistency of the purged grease each time.
Testing the hypotheses
The five hypotheses do not need to be investigated all at once. Rule them out one by one, starting with what answers quickly without instruments, such as records and side-by-side looks, and only the doubts still standing at the end need to go to a laboratory.
Records and appearance come first. If the grease type, supplier, lot or greasing method changed recently, put mixing, hypothesis 1, at the front and measure the penetration of a blend of the two (Aikin, 2023). Purged grease that is milky or shows droplets points to hypothesis 2, so follow the washing and condensation paths. Clear oil alone, with the remaining grease firm, leans towards hypothesis 3; check temperature and vibration at that point and how the pails are stored.
Temperature and amount are next. If the grease has darkened with a burnt smell, or the housing temperature rises after greasing and stays up, suspect hypothesis 4 and weigh one stroke of the gun and confirm the amount actually going in (Holdmeyer, 2022). If the grease looks like fresh grease but is soft only at high-speed or high-vibration points, look at hypothesis 5 and measure the penetration change before and after use (ASTM International, 2021b).
If that still does not settle it, run a control test. Measure, by the same method and side by side, grease taken from the housing, fresh grease scooped from the same pail and grease from a new pail. If the grease in the pail has already lost oil and softened, the problem lies in storage or in the delivered product; if the pail is sound and only the grease from the housing is soft, it happened in service. When mixing is suspected and the quick test is inconclusive, send the blend for ASTM D6185; when oil separation must be compared across supplied greases, send them for ASTM D6184 (ASTM International, 2022b, 2024b). After acting, keep recording temperature, purged-grease condition and amount at the same points on the same form; the job is done only when the trend shows run-out has actually fallen.
The hypotheses often overlap. Heat from over-greasing drives oxidation and bleeding together, and water combined with shear softens grease faster. Gear oil, hydraulic oil or cutting fluid leaking in nearby can also thin the grease, so check for leaks around the point too. When several signs appear together, fix what is easiest to correct first, such as the water path, the amount and mixing, and treat any softening that remains as a matter of the grease itself.
Limits and cautions
Values from standard tests serve specifications and quality control, so penetration, dropping point or roll stability do not translate directly into service life (ASTM International, 2021a, 2021b, 2022a). Recommended temperature ranges and relubrication amounts differ by grease and bearing, so follow the product's technical data and the bearing maker's guidance. When noise, vibration and a sudden rise in temperature appear together, bearing damage may come before any grease issue, so leave the diagnosis to maintenance staff or a bearing specialist.
Removing a grease fitting or collecting purged grease on running equipment carries the risk of rotating parts and hot surfaces, so do it only when safety procedures allow. Wear gloves and safety glasses as each product's safety data sheet, the SDS, directs when handling greases and cleaners. A grease-gun injection through the skin is more serious than it looks and needs medical care at once. Clean up leaked grease and oil promptly to prevent slips, and dispose of it under waste-oil rules.
Sources
- Aikin, A. R. (2023, May). Grease compatibility. Tribology & Lubrication Technology. https://www.stle.org/files/TLTArchives/2023/05_May/Feature.aspx
- ASTM International. (2016). ASTM D1264-16, Standard test method for determining the water washout characteristics of lubricating greases. https://webstore.ansi.org/standards/astm/astmd126416
- ASTM International. (2021a). ASTM D1831-21, Standard test method for roll stability of lubricating grease. https://store.astm.org/d1831-21.html
- ASTM International. (2021b). ASTM D217-21, Standard test methods for cone penetration of lubricating grease. https://store.astm.org/d0217-21.html
- ASTM International. (2022a). ASTM D2265-22, Standard test method for dropping point of lubricating grease over wide temperature range. https://store.astm.org/d2265-22.html
- ASTM International. (2022b). ASTM D6184-22, Standard test method for oil separation from lubricating grease (conical sieve method). https://store.astm.org/d6184-22.html
- ASTM International. (2024a). ASTM D1742-24, Standard test method for oil separation from lubricating grease during storage. https://store.astm.org/d1742-24.html
- ASTM International. (2024b). ASTM D6185-24, Standard practice for evaluating compatibility of binary mixtures of lubricating greases. https://store.astm.org/d6185-24.html
- Cyriac, F., Lugt, P. M., & Bosman, R. (2016). Impact of water on the rheology of lubricating greases. Tribology Transactions, 59(4), 679–689. https://doi.org/10.1080/10402004.2015.1107929
- Dokter, J., & Osara, J. A. (2025). On the thermal degradation of lubricant grease: Experiments. Journal of Tribology, 147(9), 091119. https://doi.org/10.1115/1.4068738
- Gebarin, S. (n.d.). Recommendations for mixing greases. Machinery Lubrication. https://www.machinerylubrication.com/Articles/Print/882
- Gurt, A., & Khonsari, M. (2025). Analysis of grease mechanical degradation in standard equipment. Tribology International, 202, 110308. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.triboint.2024.110308
- Hogenberk, F., van den Ende, D., de Rooij, M. B., & Lugt, P. M. (2025). Modeling oil-separation properties of lubricating greases. Tribology Transactions, 68(4), 872–882. https://doi.org/10.1080/10402004.2025.2516840
- Holdmeyer, D. (2022, April). Regrease properly. Tribology & Lubrication Technology. https://www.stle.org/files/TLTArchives/2022/04_April/Lubrication_Fundamentals.aspx
- Lugt, P. M. (2009). A review on grease lubrication in rolling bearings. Tribology Transactions, 52(4), 470–480. https://doi.org/10.1080/10402000802687940
- Lugt, P. M. (2013). Grease lubrication in rolling bearings. Wiley. https://www.wiley-vch.de/en/areas-interest/engineering/grease-lubrication-in-rolling-bearings-978-1-118-35391-2
- Schneidhofer, C., Schandl, M., Dörr, N., & Lugt, P. M. (2025). A model describing the oxidation rate of lubricating greases. Frontiers in Mechanical Engineering, 11. https://doi.org/10.3389/fmech.2025.1591795
- Zhou, Y. (2018). On the mechanical aging of lubricating greases [Doctoral dissertation, University of Twente]. https://utwente.nl/en/events/2018/9/309940/phd-defence-yuxin-zhou