BlogApplication notes
Why does my grease wash out with water?
- Type
- Application notes
- Published
- 20 November 2026
- Prepared by
- Technical team
- Product group
- Greases
Switching to a more water-resistant grease is the usual response to washout, but if the way water gets in stays open, even a better grease leaves by the same path. What actually strips the grease can be a thickener softened by water, washdown jets that get past the seal, a damaged or unsuitable seal, water and shear acting together, or mixing with another grease, and one or two of these can overlap.
Sometimes, the day after rain or a washdown, the area round a bearing seal has been wiped clean, or milky grease has run out of it. Refilled, it empties again after the next wash or shower, and before long rusty water shows when the housing is opened at service. If a change of grease brings the same story, it is time to work out how the water is taking the grease away.
A bearing that loses its grease loses two things at once. Grease is a semi-solid in which a thickener of fibres or particles holds the base oil, the oil that actually lubricates, like a sponge; inside the bearing it gives up oil a little at a time to form a thin film in the rolling contacts, while the rest stays near the seals as a dam against contamination (Lugt, 2009; Lugt, 2013). When grease washes out, the film and the dam go together.
Water that gets in harms the bearing in its own right. In full-scale tapered roller bearing tests, fatigue life, the running time until the surface flakes under repeated load, fell as water in the oil rose across 25, 100 and 400 parts per million (Cantley, 1977). Reports that water brings this fatigue forward go back to the 1960s (Schatzberg & Felsen, 1968). Wet lubricant can also break down at the contact and release hydrogen that enters the steel and makes it brittle, which is called hydrogen embrittlement (Stopher & Rivera-Díaz-del-Castillo, 2016). Rust in wet bearings is a big enough issue to have a standard test method of its own (ASTM International, 2022).
A grease's resistance to water does not come as one number. Washout by water (ASTM International, 2024a), spray-off by a jet (ASTM International, 2025), shear stability once wet (ASTM International, 2020) and rust protection (ASTM International, 2022) are separate tests, and researchers note that the existing tests are largely qualitative and call for more meaningful criteria (Gurt & Khonsari, 2020; Lijesh et al., 2023). So the site's water problem has to be pinned down before the right grease or fix can be chosen.
In such cases the technical team lays out the five hypotheses below and strikes them off one at a time. The starting point is always the same: scoop a little of the grease that came out and of the grease left in the bearing, and compare their colour and firmness with fresh grease from the same pail. Milky and thin means the grease has taken up water; gone but unchanged in colour and firmness means a jet pushed it out. That single look splits the hypotheses roughly in two.
Hypothesis 1: water-softened grease
If grease runs out thin where things get wet a lot, first ask whether the grease itself copes poorly with water. It shows on outdoor equipment in the rain, at points splashed with process water and where humidity is high enough for dew to form inside the housing, and it stands out in greases whose thickener dissolves readily in water. Over a few weeks of the rainy season, pale, thin grease slumps out past the seals of the idler bearings on an outdoor conveyor. Opened up, the grease left in the housing gives under a finger far more than fresh grease just scooped from the same pail.
Thickeners deal with water in different ways. One that dissolves readily, such as sodium soap, loosens its structure on meeting water and the grease thins, while one that hardly dissolves, such as the calcium types, holds its structure longer (Lugt, 2013). Water mixes into the grease as fine droplets spread evenly through the oil, an emulsion, and that changes how firm the grease is and how it flows (Gurt & Khonsari, 2020).
Even the direction of change is opposite from one thickener to another. In studies with a rheometer, an instrument that measures how grease flows and how firm it is, calcium sulfonate greases grew stiffer after absorbing a considerable amount of water, with a higher yield stress, the force needed to make grease start flowing, whereas lithium, lithium complex and polyurea greases softened (Cyriac et al., 2016). Wet calcium sulfonate complex grease did not separate its water even over long periods, because water and thickener formed an even micellar structure, made of small molecular clusters, that acted like extra thickener (Zhou et al., 2019). Softened grease is pushed outward as the bearing turns and leaks through the seal gap, and the incoming water takes its place. What looks like washout may be grease that took up water, thinned and ran out on its own.
Measuring firmness turns the judgement into a number. Firmness is measured as cone penetration, the depth a standard cone sinks into the grease, read in tenths of a millimetre, and the same value sets the NLGI consistency grade (ASTM International, 2021). Send used grease to a laboratory for penetration and water content against fresh grease, and the results show how much water it took up and how far it softened. Take one sample just after rain or a washdown and one in a dry spell; set side by side, the difference shows more clearly.
Once softened grease is confirmed, start by checking the thickener type of the current grease in its technical data. If it dissolves readily in water, consider a water-resistant thickener, and judge candidates on both the water washout test and the shear stability test with water added (ASTM International, 2020, 2024a). When changing thickener, purge as much of the old grease as possible so the mixing in hypothesis 5 does not follow. A grease that stiffens after taking up water will not run out, but its start-up torque can rise (Cyriac et al., 2017), so keep that in view on equipment that already starts hard.
Hypothesis 2: washdown jets
On equipment with scheduled washdown, grease that disappears only right after washing makes the jets the first suspect. Food and drink lines washed daily for hygiene, machines cleaned of soil with pressure washers, and places washed with hot water are the typical settings. Take a packaging line sprayed down with hot water at high pressure at the end of every working day. After the wash, the seals on bearings facing the nozzles are bare all round, and the grease left behind, picked up on a fingertip, looks and feels no different from new.
Water from a pressure washer does not seep in; it forces its way in. A strong jet pries open the seal gap and the lip, and what the grease loses here is less its insolubility than its grip on the metal, its adhesion. The standard spray test sprays water under set conditions onto grease spread on a metal plate and rates that grip by what remains, and it states that results suggest a correlation with service under direct water impingement, such as steel mill roll neck bearings (ASTM International, 2025).
The same grease can therefore stand up to standing water and still give way to a jet. The washout test and the spray test measure different properties, so one result does not predict the other (Gurt & Khonsari, 2020). The protection rating system for electrical enclosures even has a separate rating for high-pressure, high-temperature jets, a sign that a hard jet is a different load from ordinary splashing (IEC, 2013).
The washing records are the best evidence. Note the wash pressure, water temperature, distance from nozzle to bearing and spray angle, and compare grease levels by eye before and after washing. If bearings facing the nozzles empty before those on the far side, and the remaining grease has not gone soft and wet, the hypothesis fits.
Fix the washing method first. Set a work rule that jets are never aimed straight at bearing seals, and see whether pressure and water temperature above what cleaning needs can come down. If the grease is to be changed, shortlist products with good spray test results, meaning strong adhesion to metal (ASTM International, 2025). Topping up with a little grease right after washing to rebuild the dam at the seal is another option. On hygienic equipment that is washed often, check the requirements for food-grade lubricants as well.
Hypothesis 3: damaged or wrong seal
When grease empties and rust forms at only one or two positions, the seal at that spot deserves a look before the grease does. This covers seals long overdue for replacement, shafts grooved where the lip rides, and seals chosen to keep out dust but left in place where water pools or splashes. Of several pumps on the same grease, only the one standing near a floor drain has water lying in the bottom of its bearing housing at every service. With the seal out, the lip has hardened and worn on one side, and the shaft carries a shallow groove along the track where the lip ran.
In a grease-lubricated bearing, seal and grease work as a pair, because grease held near the seal fills its gap and forms a second barrier that traps incoming contamination (Lugt, 2009; Lugt, 2013). When the lip, the rubber edge of the seal that rides on the shaft and closes the gap, wears, hardens or cracks, or the shaft is grooved so the lip no longer bears evenly, water keeps coming in through the gap. Mixed with water, the grease thins as in hypothesis 1 and leaves by the same gap. A single seal defect lets water in and grease out.
A seal type that does not suit its position leads to the same result. Non-contact seals or single-lip seals meant for dust make weak barriers where water pools or splashes. The fill level is worth a look as well, since the established principle is that grease lasts longest when the bearing and housing are filled to the right level (Lugt, 2009; Lugt, 2013).
Comparing bearings on the same grease position by position brings out the clue. If one position keeps emptying or rusting, take the seal out at service and look directly for a hardened, cracked or unevenly worn lip and for grooves on the shaft. Water lying in the bottom of an opened housing, or droplets in the grease, makes the seal path the strong candidate. Log relubrication amounts and intervals too, to see whether more than the recommended amount is going in.
Replace or repair damaged seals and grooved shafts before changing the grease. Where water reaches the bearing, review seal types suited to water with the bearing maker, such as double-lip seals, a rotating flinger that throws water off, or a gutter that collects and drains it. Keep to the bearing maker's recommended relubrication amount, but at wet positions add smaller amounts more often, so the fresh grease moving towards the seal carries water and dirt out with it.
Hypothesis 4: water plus shear
Water and shear acting together show up when every bearing gets the same water but only those that turn fast or vibrate hard thin first. Fans, high-speed motors and vibrating machines in washdown areas or splash zones are the usual cases. Within one washdown area the slow transfer rollers are fine, yet creamy, thinned grease pushes out past the seals of the fast-turning fan shaft bearings alone. After relubrication they hold for a while; with continued running, grease is pushed out again.
Grease in a bearing is churned with every turn. This mechanical action is called shear, and long exposure to it breaks thickener fibres and softens the grease (Lugt, 2009). Water changes the picture. How the yield stress and start-up torque of wet grease change has been shown to depend on operating temperature, grease type and the proportion of water (Cyriac et al., 2017). That is why a grease chosen on dry shear stability alone can thin sooner than expected on a wet site.
For the same reason there is a standard test of shear stability with water mixed in. A set amount of water is mixed into the grease, it is rolled in a roll stability tester, and the change in cone penetration is read; a large rise means the structure is weak when wet. The standard states, though, that no accurate correlation with wet structural stability in service has been established, so it serves to compare candidates with each other (ASTM International, 2020).
The penetration of the used grease gives the answer. Take grease from fast and slow bearings and measure its penetration alongside fresh grease, and it becomes clear whether the side where water and shear meet has softened more (ASTM International, 2021). This is also the stage to ask the supplier whether wet roll stability results exist for the grease in use.
If the grease proved weak under wet shear, choose the next one on wet roll stability as well as dry shear stability (ASTM International, 2020). A one-step stiffer consistency grade can be considered for fast bearings, but a grease that is too stiff may not release enough oil, so weigh the choice against the bearing maker's speed limits. Any grease takes up water in the end unless the way in is closed, so carry out the seal checks from hypothesis 3 at the same time.
Hypothesis 5: grease mixing
When the water trouble dates from around the time the grease changed, mixing comes ahead of water as a suspect. That covers a switch of product or supplier, one grease gun used for several greases, and an outside maintenance contractor bringing its own grease. At a scheduled shutdown, a contractor filled the bearings with the grease its crew carries and left. Ever since, the grease empties faster than before with each rain or washdown, and what comes out is streaked in two colours.
Mix two greases with different thickeners or additives and the blend may behave like neither. The thickeners can disturb each other's structure so the blend thins, its dropping point, the temperature at which grease melts and drips, can fall, or oil can separate in storage. The grease compatibility standard compares the blend with the two original greases on three counts, dropping point, penetration after 100,000 strokes of working and storage stability at high temperature, treats a failure on any one as incompatible, and states that compatibility cannot be predicted with certainty from composition alone (ASTM International, 2024b). A softened blend leaks easily even without water, and once water reaches it, hypotheses 1 and 4 add on and it leaves much faster.
Begin by matching the lubrication records with the labels on the grease guns. If the day the grease changed, or another grease went in, sits close to the day losses rose, this hypothesis is the strong one. Grease that comes out streaked in two colours or thin only in places signals mixing, and if the picture is unclear, send a blended sample to a laboratory for penetration and dropping point (ASTM International, 2024b).
Getting the mixed grease out comes first. Remove as much of the old grease as possible from the housing and bearing and refill with the new grease. Where dismantling is hard, purge with more new grease than usual to push the old out, then watch the condition of the purged grease over the next few intervals. From then on, give each grease its own gun and label its fittings, and ask the supplier for compatibility test results before any changeover (ASTM International, 2024b).
Testing the hypotheses
A lump of grease in the hand and a few pages of records screen out much of the five hypotheses. Do the observations that need no instrument first, and only then send to a laboratory what needs a number.
First comes the state of the grease. If grease that came out and grease that stayed are milky and thin, it took up water, which points to hypothesis 1 or 4; if it vanished with colour and firmness unchanged, a jet pushed it out, as in hypothesis 2. Next, match the day losses began to the records. If it followed a grease change or the use of another grease, check hypothesis 5 first (ASTM International, 2024b); if bearings empty right after each wash, look at wash pressure and nozzle direction (ASTM International, 2025).
Position and running conditions come next. If, across positions on the same grease, one spot keeps failing, look at its seal and shaft, hypothesis 3 (Lugt, 2013); if, under the same water, fast or heavily vibrating bearings thin first, hypothesis 4 is in play (Cyriac et al., 2017). If the picture is still unclear, run a control test. Measure grease from fast and slow positions, and from wet and dry periods, for penetration and water content alongside fresh grease, and the effect of water uptake can be told apart from the effect of shear to some degree (ASTM International, 2021).
Finally, find the current grease's thickener type and its washout, spray-off and wet roll stability results in the technical data, and see whether they fit the site's water problem (Gurt & Khonsari, 2020). After the fix, keep recording grease condition, relubrication amount and washing conditions at the same positions on the same form, and judge the outcome by whether grease is still in place after several washes and rains.
Hypotheses can also link into a chain: water enters through a damaged seal, the grease takes it up, thins under rotational shear and leaves through the same seal. In that case close the ways water gets in, the seal and the washing method, first, and change the grease after that. Change only the grease and even a better one disappears by the same path.
Limits and cautions
Water resistance tests are for comparing greases with one another. The washout standard states that no correlation with field service has been established (ASTM International, 2024a), and the wet roll stability test carries the same caveat (ASTM International, 2020). Even a grease with good results needs checking at the site's own water temperature, pressure, speed and seal condition, and rust protection is tested separately from water resistance, so look at it too in wet positions (ASTM International, 2022).
If the bearing already shows noise, vibration, a rise in temperature or brown, rusty water, damage may be under way beyond the grease problem, so hand it to the bearing maker or a condition-monitoring specialist first. Stop and lock out the equipment before any service work. Handle greases and cleaners with protective gloves and eye protection as each product's safety data sheet, the SDS, directs, and dispose of used grease under local rules. For equipment that may touch food, check the relevant hygiene standards separately.
Sources
- ASTM International. (2020). ASTM D8022-20, Standard test method for roll stability of lubricating grease in presence of water (wet roll stability test). https://store.astm.org/d8022-20.html
- ASTM International. (2021). ASTM D217-21a, Standard test methods for cone penetration of lubricating grease. https://webstore.ansi.org/standards/astm/astmd21721a
- ASTM International. (2022). ASTM D1743-22, Standard test method for determining corrosion preventive properties of lubricating greases. https://store.astm.org/d1743-22.html
- ASTM International. (2024a). ASTM D1264-24a, Standard test method for determining the water washout characteristics of lubricating greases. https://webstore.ansi.org/standards/astm/astmd126424a
- ASTM International. (2024b). ASTM D6185-24, Standard practice for evaluating compatibility of binary mixtures of lubricating greases. https://store.astm.org/d6185-24.html
- ASTM International. (2025). ASTM D4049-25, Standard test method for determining the resistance of lubricating grease to water spray. https://store.astm.org/d4049-25.html
- Cantley, R. E. (1977). The effect of water in lubricating oil on bearing fatigue life. ASLE Transactions, 20(3), 244–248. https://doi.org/10.1080/05698197708982838
- Cyriac, F., Lugt, P. M., & Bosman, R. (2016). Impact of water on the rheology of lubricating greases. Tribology Transactions, 59(4), 679–689. https://doi.org/10.1080/10402004.2015.1107929
- Cyriac, F., Lugt, P. M., & Bosman, R. (2017). The impact of water on the yield stress and startup torque of lubricating greases. Tribology Transactions, 60(5), 824–831. https://doi.org/10.1080/10402004.2016.1215583
- Gurt, A., & Khonsari, M. M. (2020). An overview of grease water resistance. Lubricants, 8(9), 86. https://doi.org/10.3390/lubricants8090086
- International Electrotechnical Commission [IEC]. (2013). IEC 60529:1989/AMD2:2013, Degrees of protection provided by enclosures (IP Code), Amendment 2. https://webstore.iec.ch/publication/2446
- Lijesh, K. P., Miller, R. A., Shah, R., Shirvani, K., & Khonsari, M. M. (2023). The standard for assessing water resistance properties of lubricating grease using contact angle measurements. Lubricants, 11(10), 440. https://doi.org/10.3390/lubricants11100440
- Lugt, P. M. (2009). A review on grease lubrication in rolling bearings. Tribology Transactions, 52(4), 470–480. https://doi.org/10.1080/10402000802687940
- Lugt, P. M. (2013). Grease lubrication in rolling bearings. Wiley. https://www.wiley-vch.de/en/areas-interest/engineering/grease-lubrication-in-rolling-bearings-978-1-118-35391-2
- Schatzberg, P., & Felsen, I. M. (1968). Effects of water and oxygen during rolling contact lubrication. Wear, 12(5), 331–342. https://doi.org/10.1016/0043-1648(68)90536-X
- Stopher, M. A., & Rivera-Díaz-del-Castillo, P. E. J. (2016). Hydrogen embrittlement in bearing steels. Materials Science and Technology, 32(11), 1184–1193. https://doi.org/10.1080/02670836.2016.1156810
- Zhou, Y., Bosman, R., & Lugt, P. M. (2019). On the shear stability of dry and water-contaminated calcium sulfonate complex lubricating greases. Tribology Transactions, 62, 626–634. https://doi.org/10.1080/10402004.2019.1588445