KALTEC

BlogApplication notes

Why have surface finish and dimensions got worse?

Type
Application notes
Published
20 November 2026
Prepared by
Technical team
Product group
Metalworking Fluids (MWF)

Changing the tool is the usual first move when finish turns rough and size wanders, but a new tool does nothing about the fluid's concentration, temperature or filtration. What actually unsettles finish and size can be concentration drift, thermal distortion, built-up edge, unfiltered fines, or tool wear and chatter, and one of these can feed another.

Parts made in the afternoon start to land at the edge of tolerance at inspection, and the surface shows tearing or scratches that were not there before. Neither the program nor the tool has changed, yet morning and afternoon parts measure differently, and the surface texture varies even within one day. With no obvious change to point at, the tool gets swapped and the settings adjusted, but a few days later the same thing happens again.

Finish and size are acceptance criteria set as numbers on the drawing, so a part outside them has to be reworked or scrapped, and the line slows while the cause is found. Dimensions are defined at a reference temperature, and the international standard ISO 1 sets that reference at 20 °C (ISO, 2016). That is why the same part measures differently hot and after cooling, and precision-machining research has long treated thermal error as a large share of machine-tool error (Bryan, 1990; Ramesh et al., 2000).

A metalworking fluid does three jobs: it removes heat, lubricates the contact between edge and workpiece, and flushes chips away (Brinksmeier et al., 2015). It is the main means of removing heat, and also a carrier that warms up and moves heat around the machine (Mayr et al., 2012). When one of these jobs fails, finish and size suffer together, and causes on the tool side that have nothing to do with the fluid produce the same symptoms. So the fluid is both a candidate cause and the first clue that can be checked.

In such cases the technical team sets up the five hypotheses below and rules them out one by one. The first check is always the same: on the same day, measure coolant concentration and sump temperature, and set them beside the times the bad parts came off and the tool-change log.

Hypothesis 1: concentration drift

Concentration tends to wander in summer when a lot of water evaporates, on lines where chips and parts carry out a lot of fluid, and on sumps topped up with only water or only concentrate whenever the level drops. Picture a sump that is filled with water from a hose on Friday afternoon because the level is down, then gets concentrate poured in by feel early the next week. The concentration column on the check sheet has been blank for weeks, and the operators only say there seems to be a bit more foam lately.

Concentration matters to the surface because of what the concentrate contains. In a water-mix fluid the lubricating and anti-rust components come in the concentrate, so concentration is a direct measure of how much of them is present. As water evaporates concentration rises, and when what leaves on chips and parts is replaced with water only, it falls (HSE, 2021). Guidance from the US Occupational Safety and Health Administration, OSHA, notes that low concentration may shorten tool life, while too high a concentration may cause dermatitis and foaming (OSHA, n.d.).

The effect of concentration on finish can be smaller than expected, though. In turning tests on a titanium alloy, roughness depended strongly on feed and tool type, and concentration had little influence (Gariani et al., 2021). Rather than creating a large defect on its own, concentration drift can feed the other hypotheses by weakening lubrication so that built-up edge and tool wear arrive sooner (Brinksmeier et al., 2015; OSHA, n.d.). That is why concentration is set right before the other hypotheses are tested.

A refractometer is the quickest check. The UK Health and Safety Executive, HSE, advises measuring concentration with a refractometer, together with pH, every week (HSE, 2021). Multiply the scale reading by the refractometer factor on the product data sheet to get the actual concentration, and look in the log for a repeating pattern of rises in summer or after long runs and falls after water top-ups. More foam and sticky parts point to high concentration; rust together with shorter tool life points to low (OSHA, n.d.).

Set one target value within the supplier's recommended range, and log readings and top-up volumes on the same sheet. Because evaporation raises concentration, top up not with water alone but with fluid premixed below the recommended concentration (HSE, 2021). If finish and size stay the same once concentration is right, take that state as the baseline and move on to the next hypothesis.

Hypothesis 2: thermal distortion

This is the hypothesis when size moves with the time of day. It shows in workshops where morning and afternoon temperatures differ widely, at the first start after a weekend stop when the machine is fully cold, and on machines whose small sump or low level lets the fluid warm quickly. A boring operation is a case in point: on Monday morning the first part sits at one end of the tolerance, by lunchtime it is in the middle, and in the afternoon it crosses to the other end. The only thing that changed in between was the clock.

Heat comes from many places and spreads through the fluid. During machining, the cut itself, spindle bearings, axis motors, hydraulics and the coolant pump all generate heat. The fluid takes up that heat and carries it back to the sump, and as the sump warms it heats the workpiece, table and fixtures in turn (Mayr et al., 2012). Metal expands as it warms, so a size hit on a warm part shrinks after cooling, and as the spindle and column grow, the tool tip position shifts little by little (Bryan, 1990; Mayr et al., 2012).

This change does not arrive at once but builds over hours. Machine-tool error research treats thermal error as important enough to have its own methods of measurement and compensation (Ramesh et al., 2000), and the standard ISO 230-3 defines separate tests for error from changes in ambient temperature and for thermal distortion from spindle rotation and axis motion (ISO, 2020). Thermal distortion, in other words, mixes contributions from the room, the machine and the fluid.

Putting the records on a time axis is the first step. On the same program, log each part's measurement with the time, plot it, and see whether size drifts one way for some hours after start-up and then settles. HSE advises measuring sump fluid temperature weekly (HSE, 2021), but when size is a problem, measure it several times a day and match it to room temperature and the dimension log. A large gap between a reading taken at the machine right after machining and one taken in the inspection room after the part has settled means workpiece temperature is part of the cause (ISO, 2016). A low level means less fluid takes the same heat and warms faster, so check the level log as well.

The remedy lies in both cooling and measuring practice. If sump temperature is clearly above the room and size follows it, fit or upsize a coolant chiller and keep the level steady. Before the first cut of the morning, add a warm-up cycle that runs the spindle and axes so the machine works at a stable temperature. Make it the rule to measure parts once they have settled, and if machine-side distortion is large, ask the machine builder to check its thermal compensation (Mayr et al., 2012).

Hypothesis 3: built-up edge

It tends to appear when soft, sticky materials such as low-carbon steel, aluminium and stainless steel are cut at low speed (Trent & Wright, 2000), and also when the nozzle misses the cutting edge. Here is how it looks on a line finishing aluminium housings. Some parts come off with patches that look dull and torn, and a fingernail drawn across them catches on small metal fragments. Even within one part, bright areas sit next to dull ones.

The chip slides over the rake face, the top face of the edge that the chip rides over, under high pressure and heat. With sticky materials, some of it welds onto the edge and piles up, and this lump of workpiece material stuck to the edge is called built-up edge. It grows, breaks off at a certain size, and its fragments stick to the machined surface or tear it (Trent & Wright, 2000).

While built-up edge is in place, the actual position and shape of the cutting edge change, so size shifts slightly and the surface texture turns uneven. How it forms and breaks away depends on material, tool coating and friction, and when it breaks away it can pull tool material with it and speed up wear (Fox-Rabinovich et al., 2020). The lubricating components of the fluid form a thin film between edge and chip that reduces friction and adhesion, which is why preventing built-up edge counts among the main functions of a coolant (Brinksmeier et al., 2015; Kui et al., 2021). When lubrication weakens, the film breaks and built-up edge grows back.

Pulling the tool and looking at the edge settles it quickly. Through a loupe a shiny lump sits on the edge, and the symptom changes when cutting speed changes (Trent & Wright, 2000). On the fluid side, check concentration and nozzle aim. If the fluid does not reach the edge, lubrication falls short even at the right concentration.

If a lump shows on the edge, bring concentration back into range and aim the nozzle at the edge first. If it persists, raise cutting speed within the tool maker's recommended range, or move to a sharper tool or a coating less prone to adhesion (Fox-Rabinovich et al., 2020; Trent & Wright, 2000). On a line that mainly cuts sticky materials, review with the supplier whether a grade with stronger lubricating components fits better (Brinksmeier et al., 2015).

Hypothesis 4: unfiltered fines

Typical settings are processes that make a lot of very small particles, such as grinding, honing and cast iron machining, central systems that feed many machines from one sump, and machines whose filters have not been changed for a long time. Take a line where a central sump feeds several grinders: fine scratches that do not follow the grinding direction start to appear on finish-ground shafts, the fluid from the nozzle is slightly cloudy, and the filter change date is long past.

The scratches come from unfiltered particles making the trip back. Large chips are caught by the conveyor and screens, but very small particles such as fine chips and wheel debris stay suspended in the fluid and remain in the sump. The pump sends them back to the nozzle, and when a particle is trapped between the tool or wheel and the workpiece, it leaves a scratch or mark. In grinding tests, adding hard particles to the fluid clearly increased surface waviness, and the larger the particles relative to the wheel's grains, the faster the wheel wore (Beekhuis, 2013).

Fine particles clump with tramp oil, the lubricating and hydraulic oil that leaks from the machine, into sludge on the sump floor and in pipes, and they clog screens and filters (HSE, 2021; OSHA, n.d.). A clogged filter cuts flow to the nozzle and weakens cooling and chip flushing too, so scratches and thermal distortion can appear together. HSE advises removing fines with centrifuges or filtration, or with magnetic separators for ferrous materials (HSE, 2021).

Suspect this hypothesis when scratches do not follow the cutting direction and some marks have tails. A settling test is a simple check: collect fluid from the nozzle in a clear jar, leave it for a day, and compare the sediment week by week. Check filters and screens regularly for blockage (HSE, 2021), and if there is a differential-pressure gauge, log its trend. Look at sludge depth on the sump floor and the amount of tramp oil too; the advice is to keep tramp oil below 2% (HSE, 2021).

The tighter the finish requirement, the smaller the particles the filtration has to catch. Find out what particle size the current filter removes, and if settling-test sediment and surface scratches have risen together, move to a finer grade or add a magnetic separator or centrifuge (Beekhuis, 2013; HSE, 2021). Clear sludge from the sump floor regularly with the machine stopped, and take tramp oil off with a skimmer (HSE, 2021; OSHA, n.d.).

Hypothesis 5: tool wear or chatter

This one is checked alongside the others because no amount of work on the fluid will remove it. It shows in processes with no set tool-change interval, where tools run until they give out, in deep pockets cut with long tool overhang, and on thin-walled parts or weakly clamped workpieces. Consider a long end mill finishing the walls of a deep pocket. The cut gives off a sharp noise, and a fingertip run along the finished wall feels evenly spaced waves.

Take wear first. As the edge wears, its tip recedes and size changes slightly on the same program, and a worn edge rubs rather than cuts cleanly, roughening the surface. Low concentration can speed this wear up (OSHA, n.d.).

Chatter is vibration that feeds itself. When an edge cuts the wavy surface left by the previous edge, chip thickness rises and falls, and the changing force drives the vibration further. So whether a cut is stable depends on the combination of depth of cut and spindle speed, and chatter leaves a regular wave pattern on the surface and unsettles size as well (Altintas & Weck, 2004).

Matching against the tool-change log separates the two. If finish and size recover with a new tool and then worsen over time, it is wear. A sharp noise together with evenly spaced waves on the surface means chatter; see also whether the spacing changes with spindle speed (Altintas & Weck, 2004).

For wear, match the tool-change interval to actual life, and read the concentration log for the same period to see whether poor lubrication shortened it (OSHA, n.d.). For chatter, change spindle speed or reduce depth of cut, and check tool overhang and clamping (Altintas & Weck, 2004). Neither goes away with a fluid change, so it pays to rule them out before acting on the fluid.

Testing the hypotheses

There is no need to dig into all five hypotheses at once. Rule them out one at a time, starting with what can be measured on the spot and what clears the way for the others.

Settle the tool and the concentration first. Run the same job with a new tool and listen and look for wave patterns, and hypothesis 5 is screened (Altintas & Weck, 2004). Then measure concentration with a refractometer and bring it into range (HSE, 2021). Make every later judgement from this state, or the other hypotheses will not get a fair test.

Time comes next. If size logged with the time drifts one way through the day, the lead is hypothesis 2, and tank and room temperatures should be recorded alongside (HSE, 2021; Mayr et al., 2012). The gap between readings at the machine and in the inspection room shows how much is workpiece temperature (ISO, 2016).

The look of the surface separates hypotheses 3 and 4. Under magnification, tearing and stuck fragments mean built-up edge, and scratches with no direction mean fine chips (Beekhuis, 2013; Trent & Wright, 2000). If fines are suspected, check the settling test, filter blockage and tramp oil level (HSE, 2021). Make one change at a time and log the result, or there is no telling which change worked; the last check is to see that size by time of day and surface condition stay in range for some days after the fix.

The hypotheses are tangled together. A clogged filter cuts flow and weakens cooling, bringing scratches and thermal drift at once, and low concentration raises built-up edge and tool wear together (Brinksmeier et al., 2015; OSHA, n.d.). In that case, correct what feeds the others, concentration and filtration, first, and only then look again at what remains.

Limits and cautions

Machine faults such as spindle bearing damage, axis backlash, loss of machine level or fixture distortion cannot be found by checking the fluid. If the symptom remains after changing tool and fluid, hand diagnosis to the machine builder or a service specialist, and leave thermal compensation and machine accuracy tests to specialists as well (ISO, 2020; Mayr et al., 2012). Control ranges differ by product, so follow the product data sheet and the supplier's recommended range.

When measuring and handling coolant, follow the product's safety data sheet, the SDS, and wear protective gloves and safety glasses. Inhaling coolant mist can cause respiratory disease, and skin contact can cause dermatitis (HSE, 2021; NIOSH, 1998). The US National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health, NIOSH, recommends an exposure limit for metalworking fluid aerosol of 0.4 mg/m³ as thoracic particulate mass, the small particles that reach the airways and lungs, averaged over the work shift (NIOSH, 1998). Clear sump sludge wearing gloves and only with the machine stopped (HSE, 2021).

Sources

  1. Altintas, Y., & Weck, M. (2004). Chatter stability of metal cutting and grinding. CIRP Annals, 53(2), 619–642. https://doi.org/10.1016/S0007-8506(07)60032-8
  2. Beekhuis, B. (2013). Influence of solid contaminants in metal working fluids on the grinding process. Advanced Materials Research, 769, 61–68. https://doi.org/10.4028/www.scientific.net/AMR.769.61
  3. Brinksmeier, E., Meyer, D., Huesmann-Cordes, A., & Herrmann, C. (2015). Metalworking fluids—Mechanisms and performance. CIRP Annals, 64(2), 605–628. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cirp.2015.05.003
  4. Bryan, J. (1990). International status of thermal error research (1990). CIRP Annals, 39(2), 645–656. https://doi.org/10.1016/S0007-8506(07)63001-7
  5. Fox-Rabinovich, G., Gershman, I., Yamamoto, K., Dosbaeva, J., & Veldhuis, S. (2020). Effect of the adaptive response on the wear behavior of PVD and CVD coated cutting tools during machining with built up edge formation. Nanomaterials, 10(12), 2489. https://doi.org/10.3390/nano10122489
  6. Gariani, S., El-Sayed, M., & Shyha, I. (2021). Optimisation of cutting fluid concentration and operating parameters based on RSM for turning Ti–6Al–4V. The International Journal of Advanced Manufacturing Technology, 117, 539–553. https://doi.org/10.1007/s00170-021-07623-0
  7. Health and Safety Executive [HSE]. (2021). MW5, Managing fluid quality: COSHH essentials for machining with metalworking fluids. https://www.hse.gov.uk/pubns/guidance/mw5.pdf
  8. International Organization for Standardization [ISO]. (2016). ISO 1:2016, Geometrical product specifications (GPS) — Standard reference temperature for the specification of geometrical and dimensional properties. https://www.iso.org/standard/67630.html
  9. International Organization for Standardization [ISO]. (2020). ISO 230-3:2020, Test code for machine tools — Part 3: Determination of thermal effects. https://www.iso.org/standard/73291.html
  10. Kui, G., Islam, S., Reddy, M., Khandoker, N., & Chen, V. (2021). Recent progress and evolution of coolant usages in conventional machining methods: A comprehensive review. The International Journal of Advanced Manufacturing Technology, 119, 3–40. https://doi.org/10.1007/s00170-021-08182-0
  11. Mayr, J., Jedrzejewski, J., Uhlmann, E., Donmez, M. A., Knapp, W., Härtig, F., Wendt, K., Moriwaki, T., Shore, P., Schmitt, R., Brecher, C., Würz, T., & Wegener, K. (2012). Thermal issues in machine tools. CIRP Annals, 61(2), 771–791. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cirp.2012.05.008
  12. National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health [NIOSH]. (1998). Criteria for a recommended standard: Occupational exposure to metalworking fluids (DHHS [NIOSH] Publication No. 98-102). https://www.cdc.gov/niosh/docs/98-102/
  13. Occupational Safety and Health Administration [OSHA]. (n.d.). Metalworking fluids: Safety and health best practices manual. U.S. Department of Labor. https://www.osha.gov/metalworking-fluids/manual
  14. Ramesh, R., Mannan, M., & Poo, A. (2000). Error compensation in machine tools — A review. Part II: Thermal errors. International Journal of Machine Tools and Manufacture, 40(9), 1257–1284. https://doi.org/10.1016/S0890-6955(00)00010-9
  15. Trent, E. M., & Wright, P. K. (2000). Metal cutting (4th ed.). Butterworth-Heinemann.

Product and site consultation

Leave your company, site and the product groups in use. Our engineer will get in touch to go through your site conditions and concerns. Materials, equipment, operating conditions and downstream steps show what should change and what can stay. If nothing needs to change, we will say so.

Contact us
After you contact us
  1. 01
    Site setup

    We confirm process conditions and needs first.

  2. 02
    Spec design

    We set the product spec and selection criteria.

  3. 03
    Comparison

    We compare matching candidates and propose.

  4. 04
    Tailored supply

    We supply on time and manage the stock.

  5. 05
    Site check

    We visit, check conditions of use and record.

  6. 06
    Use management

    We track use and change cycles to catch issues.

  7. 07
    Regular analysis

    We analyze the records and send a yearly report.