BlogApplication notes
Why did problems start after switching products?
- Type
- Application notes
- Published
- 20 November 2026
- Prepared by
- Technical team
- Product group
- General
Blaming the new product and switching back is the usual response to trouble after a change, but the same product can behave differently depending on how the change was made and what it meets on site. What actually causes the trouble can be leftover old product mixing in, seals that swell or shrink, damaged plastics and paint, aluminium staining, film left on parts or a mismatch with wastewater treatment, and sometimes two or more at once.
A few days after a switch to a new product, filters start plugging sooner than usual; a few weeks on, oil marks spread under a gearbox, and the paint line reports crater-shaped defects it never had before. The product passed its trials, which makes it all the more puzzling. Going straight back to the old product, though, leaves the cause unknown, and the same thing happens again at the next change.
The cost lands in three places. On the equipment side come leaks, filter changes and downtime; on the quality side, stained parts and paint defects; on the environment and safety side, effluent limit breaches and skin exposure. For metalworking fluids, public guidance says to drain and clean the system before charging new fluid, because residual fluid contaminates the new charge (NIOSH, 1998; OSHA, n.d.).
Industrial chemicals are formulations in which base oil, additives, surfactants and water are balanced against one another. When components from another formulation mix in, that balance can break and the product may not perform as designed, and even when both products meet their own specifications, the mixture is hard to predict (Fitch, n.d.; Samman, n.d.). On top of that, the new product was tested on its own, but on site it meets leftover old product, aged seals and paint, and the processes that follow, all at once.
In such cases the technical team sets up the six hypotheses below and rules them out one by one. The start is always the same: set the date, place and symptoms of the trouble beside the changeover record, meaning how the system was drained, cleaned and filled, and how much old product was left behind.
Hypothesis 1: leftover old product
When symptoms appear within days of the change, look first at leftover old product. Typical cases are filling with new product after draining only the tank and leaving lines and heat exchangers as they were, changing over gradually by topping up with the new product, and packing new grease on top of the old without purging it. A hydraulic tank is drained and refilled with new fluid over a weekend, and from Monday afternoon the return filter's differential pressure gauge climbs faster than usual. A look through the inspection port shows sticky sediment lying on the tank bottom.
Old product stays in lines, tank bottoms, heat exchangers and filter housings even after draining. When the new product arrives the two additive packages meet, and different additives can react to form insoluble products or cancel each other's function (Fitch, n.d.). Insoluble products become sludge and sediment that plug filters early, and when foam suppression and air release weaken, foam increases. This can happen even between products of the same type from one maker if their additive treatments differ (Fitch, n.d.).
Grease is more sensitive. When the thickener, the component that holds oil in a semi-solid form, differs, the mix can soften or bleed oil, and its dropping point, the temperature at which it starts to flow, can fall (ASTM International, 2024; Samman, n.d.). Even greases with the same thickener can be incompatible because of their additives (Samman, n.d.). With water-mix metalworking fluids, what remains is not only chemistry. If bacterial and fungal films and sludge stay on tank walls and in lines, they feed on the new fluid at once and grow back, so odour, falling pH and foam can return right after the change.
Filters and the tank bottom give the first answer. Suspect mixing when, within days of the change, the differential pressure across the filter rises fast, sticky sediment forms in the tank bottom, or colour and turbidity change (Fitch, n.d.). For oils, keep samples from before and after the change and compare particle count, viscosity and water separation. For grease, look for softened grease or oil running out of bearings, and judge the compatibility of two greases with the standard practice ASTM D6185, which compares dropping point, mechanical stability and storage stability at several mixing ratios (ASTM International, 2024).
Without compatibility data, plan the change as if the products were incompatible (Fitch, n.d.). Where the risk is high, drain fully, circulate a flushing fluid, remove it, then fill with the new product; where the risk is low, a gradual change by topping up with the new product can work. Do not mix greases; purge the old grease out with the new one (ASTM International, 2024). For water-mix metalworking fluids, kill organisms before draining, remove chips and sludge, circulate a cleaner, then rinse and refill (NIOSH, 1998; OSHA, n.d.). For a few weeks after the change, shorten the sampling interval to catch problems early.
Hypothesis 2: seal volume change
If leaks grow little by little over weeks rather than right after the change, the seals are the suspect. It often shows after a move from an aromatic-rich mineral oil to a highly refined or synthetic oil, or after a change to a different base-oil family with old seals left in place. A few weeks after the change, oil starts to bead under a hydraulic cylinder rod, and a thin oil mark spreads around the pump shaft.
A rubber seal absorbs part of the fluid it touches, or loses components such as plasticiser into the fluid. Its volume, hardness, tensile strength and elongation, how far it stretches before breaking, change as a result, and when the change is large the seal stops working (ASTM International, 2021). In mineral oils, more aromatic content, meaning ring-shaped hydrocarbons, swells rubber more, and the aniline point estimates that content: the lower the aniline point, the more aromatics and the stronger the swell (ASTM International, 2023).
Apply this to a product change and the leak makes sense. Switching from an aromatic-rich oil to one with few aromatics lets a seal that had settled into a swollen state shrink and open a gap. Excessive swell, in turn, deforms the seal and it leaks as well (ASTM International, 2021, 2023). Additives affect seals as well as base oil. A study of fluoroelastomer seals in synthetic oils used oils with the same base but different additives to see how seal compatibility changes (Bulut et al., 2020).
A removed seal is the firmest evidence. Compare its thickness and hardness with a new seal, and look for cracking or tackiness. Where more confirmation is needed, run ASTM D471, an immersion test that soaks the actual seal material in the new product and measures the change in volume and hardness (ASTM International, 2021). A static immersion test, however, does not reproduce every condition of a moving seal (ASTM International, 2021; Bulut et al., 2020).
Seals are best dealt with before the change. List the seal materials in the equipment and get compatibility data for those materials from the new supplier. If the change crosses base-oil families, from mineral oil to synthetic hydrocarbon, ester or glycol, replacing aged seals at the same time is the safer course. If leaks have already started, replace the seals at the leak points first and inspect other seals of the same material more often.
Hypothesis 3: plastic, paint damage
Cracks in clear windows or covers, or equipment paint starting to lift, can be a sign that ingredients in the new product are attacking the material. This tends to follow a change of water-mix product or cleaner, with plastic windows bolted down tight that are often splashed, and with moves to a very different fluid family, such as a fire-resistant hydraulic fluid. On the clear window of a machine door, fine cracks run out from the bolt holes, and paint inside the tank lifts in thin flakes under a fingernail.
Polycarbonate, widely used for clear windows and covers, cracks at much lower strain than usual when it is under stress and touches certain liquids; this is called environmental stress cracking (Al-Saidi et al., 2003; Faulkner, 1985). Amines such as monoethanolamine and surfactants have been reported as stress-cracking agents for polycarbonate (Faulkner, 1985), and solvents such as alcohols and glycol ethers sharply reduced its strength (Al-Saidi et al., 2003). A product change alters the type and amount of these ingredients, so cracks can start where bolts hold the part under stress.
Paint fails by a different route. When a liquid soaks into a coating and swells or softens it, the coating lifts and peels. For a change to a fluid of a very different family, such as a fire-resistant hydraulic fluid, an international standard advises checking every component in the circuit, seals, hoses and paint included, and draining and cleaning the circuit (ISO, 2024).
Look at the pattern of the cracks first. Fine cracks running from bolt holes or edges, or a hazy network of fine surface cracks known as crazing, point to stress cracking. Check too whether paint inside tanks, around lines and on machine panels blisters or peels easily under a fingernail. Soaking a piece of the suspect material in the new product, or applying the product to a bent, stressed coupon and watching it for a few days, shows the tendency (Faulkner, 1985).
A window that has started to crack has already lost strength, so replace it rather than rely on it for protection. When refitting, avoid over-tightening to keep stress low, and before the next change, identify the plastics, paints and hose materials the product will touch and get the supplier's material compatibility data. If the paint cannot withstand the new fluid, either return to the previous product or move to a coating that resists it (ISO, 2024).
Hypothesis 4: aluminium staining
This is the hypothesis when the process is unchanged but yellowish or dark stains appear on aluminium parts from the time of the change. Typical settings are a change of water-mix metalworking fluid or cleaner, parts stacked wet or left waiting a long time for washing, and lines that carry aluminium and steel parts together. Machined aluminium housings are stacked wet in a basket, and when they come out the next day, stains have spread along the faces that touched.
Aluminium owes its corrosion resistance to a thin oxide layer on its surface. In alkaline liquids such as water-mix metalworking fluids and cleaners, that layer dissolves and leaves stains ranging from light yellow to dark grey (Canter, 2020). Some alkanolamines, the alkaline amine ingredients used for pH control, make staining worse, and water hardness, chloride and contact with steel add to it. In contact with steel, an electrochemical reaction makes the aluminium corrode first; this is galvanic corrosion (Canter, 2020). So if the new product runs at a slightly higher pH or uses a different inhibitor package, stains can appear that the same process never produced before.
Concentration needs weighing too. The refractometer factor, the value that turns the scale reading into real concentration, differs by product, so if the old product's factor is still in use, real concentration drifts from what is intended, and if it drifts high, pH can rise with it.
Recording where the stains form is the first check. Note whether they appear only on certain alloys, or where parts stay wet for a long time, such as in stacks or while waiting for washing. Measure the working fluid's pH, concentration, hardness and chloride and compare them with records from before the change, and confirm that the refractometer factor in use is the one on the new product's data sheet. Immersing alloy coupons in the working fluid overnight at a set temperature shows the tendency (Canter, 2020).
The first job is to re-measure concentration with the new product's factor and bring it into the maker's recommended range. Move drying and washing earlier so that parts do not stay wet for long. If stains persist, ask the supplier for test results on the alloy in question and consider a product designed for aluminium (Canter, 2020).
Hypothesis 5: film left on parts
Sometimes equipment and parts look fine, yet defects rise further down the line. What to look at then is film left on the parts. It becomes a problem when a cutting fluid or rust preventive is changed while the cleaning conditions stay the same, on lines where painting, bonding or conversion coating, which forms a thin protective layer on metal before painting, comes next, and after a move to a product with a silicone defoamer or additive. In the first week after the change, brackets come out of the washer and through the paint booth with small round defects, sunken in the centre, dotted across the coating.
Craters form when a low-surface-tension contaminant sits under or on a wet coating. The difference in surface tension between the contaminated spot and the surrounding paint pulls the paint outward, leaving a round defect with a sunken centre (Schoff, 2016). Oils, greases, silicones and waxes are typical, and very small amounts can cause them (Schoff, 2016). If the new product's oil phase, its extreme-pressure additives, which protect metal surfaces under heavy load, or its silicone defoamer differ from the old one, the existing cleaning conditions may not remove the film, and the problem only shows at painting, bonding or conversion coating.
Running water over a cleaned part is the simplest check. If the water film breaks or beads up instead of staying even, that signals an oily film or similar contamination on the surface. For a quantitative check, use ASTM D7334, the standard method for measuring the contact angle of a water drop; a high contact angle signals an oily film on the surface (ASTM International, 2022). Check the quality records too for a rise in craters, water beading or bonding failures from the date of the change.
Where film looks like the cause, reset the cleaning conditions, such as cleaner type, concentration, temperature and time, together with the people who run the downstream process. In a plant with a paint line, always ask whether the new product contains silicone, and run trial cleaning and trial painting on parts first (Schoff, 2016). If cleaning does not solve it, revisit the product choice.
Hypothesis 6: wastewater mismatch
Sometimes the call comes from the wastewater plant well after the change. Think of a water-mix product changed while the treatment chemicals and doses stayed the same, plants that handle spent fluid by membrane separation or biological treatment, and changeovers where old product, new product and flushing fluid wastes went into one container. In the treatment tank, the oil layer no longer rises as clearly as before, and the water below stays cloudy.
Spent water-mix product is an emulsion of fine oil droplets in water, so treatment separates oil from water by chemical demulsification, which breaks the emulsion with chemicals, by membrane separation or by biological treatment (Cheng et al., 2005). The chemical type and dose in these processes are set for the emulsifiers and oil content of the current product. If the new product's emulsifiers form a more stable emulsion, the same chemicals separate less, and oil and chemical oxygen demand, or COD, a measure of organic matter in water, can rise in the treated water (Cheng et al., 2005).
Storage adds risk. Mixing wastes of different chemicals can cause reactions such as heat and gas generation, and a US Environmental Protection Agency report gives a method and chart for judging whether two wastes can be combined (Hatayama et al., 1980). That is why wastes of the old product, the new product and the flushing fluid need checking before they share a container.
Start with the treatment operator's records. If, after the change, less oil floats up in the treatment tank, membrane flux drops, or oil content and COD rise in the treated water, this hypothesis is the strong one. A jar test, which splits the new product's waste into portions treated at different chemical doses, sorts out the cause quickly.
Once a wastewater mismatch is clear, make it standard for the next change to give the treatment operator a sample and the safety data sheet of the new product at the planning stage, so the treatment conditions are tested in advance. During the changeover, collect wastes of the old product, the new product and the flushing fluid separately (Hatayama et al., 1980). If treatment cannot meet the limits, use an outside contractor for the time being and retune the conditions with the treatment chemical supplier.
Testing the hypotheses
Six hypotheses do not need six investigations at once. When the symptoms began is the biggest clue, so start by setting the date, place and symptoms beside the changeover record. The date alone separates most of the hypotheses.
If filter plugging, sediment, foam or a colour change came within days, look first at residual mixing, hypothesis 1, and compare samples from before and after (Fitch, n.d.). If leaks grow over weeks, check the seals under hypothesis 2; if windows crack or paint lifts, check hypothesis 3. For both, the first check is to compare removed parts with new ones, moving on to an immersion test if needed (ASTM International, 2021; Faulkner, 1985).
Stains only on certain alloys point to hypothesis 4. Confirm first that the refractometer factor is the new product's, then measure pH, concentration and hardness and run an immersion test (Canter, 2020). If equipment and parts look fine but downstream defects rise, treat it as hypothesis 5 and check cleaned surfaces with a water-break check and contact angle (ASTM International, 2022). Finally, check the wastewater records for a change in effluent quality, and if there is one, run a jar test on the new product's waste to confirm hypothesis 6 (Cheng et al., 2005).
Once the field narrows, settle it with a control test that puts the old and new products side by side under the same conditions. Immersion of seal and plastic pieces, immersion of alloy coupons and jar tests on waste all show the difference most clearly with the two products next to each other. Laboratory results can differ from real service, though (ASTM International, 2021; Bulut et al., 2020), so the check is complete only after a few weeks of shorter sampling intervals show the symptom has not returned.
The hypotheses can overlap. Seals can shrink in a system that also holds leftover old product, and a plant that changed its water-mix product can see aluminium stains and wastewater trouble in the same period. When causes overlap, act first on those that bear directly on equipment damage and safety, such as leaks and cracked windows, then order the quality and wastewater issues by the test results.
Limits and cautions
Compatibility differs with every product combination, so base decisions on tests with the actual materials and products, and on data from the equipment maker and the product supplier. The grease compatibility standard itself states that compatibility cannot be predicted with certainty from composition (ASTM International, 2024), and laboratory tests such as immersion tests can differ from real service conditions (ASTM International, 2021; Bulut et al., 2020).
Before changeover and cleaning work, check the safety data sheets, the SDS, of the old product, the new product and the flushing fluid, and wear skin and eye protection. Metalworking fluids have guidance on controlling mist and skin contact, so keep the same standards during the changeover (NIOSH, 1998; OSHA, n.d.). Decide conversions to fire-resistant hydraulic fluids, changes that affect a paint line and issues tied to effluent limits together with the equipment maker, the paint shop and the environmental staff (ISO, 2024).
Sources
- Al-Saidi, L. F., Mortensen, K., & Almdal, K. (2003). Environmental stress cracking resistance. Behaviour of polycarbonate in different chemicals by determination of the time-dependence of stress at constant strains. Polymer Degradation and Stability, 82(3), 451–461. https://doi.org/10.1016/S0141-3910(03)00199-X
- ASTM International. (2021). ASTM D471-16a(2021), Standard test method for rubber property—Effect of liquids. https://store.astm.org/d0471-16a.html
- ASTM International. (2022). ASTM D7334-08(2022), Standard practice for surface wettability of coatings, substrates and pigments by advancing contact angle measurement. https://store.astm.org/d7334-08r22.html
- ASTM International. (2023). ASTM D611-23, Standard test methods for aniline point and mixed aniline point of petroleum products and hydrocarbon solvents. https://store.astm.org/d0611-23.html
- ASTM International. (2024). ASTM D6185-24, Standard practice for evaluating compatibility of binary mixtures of lubricating greases. https://store.astm.org/d6185-24.html
- Bulut, D., Krups, T., Poll, G., & Giese, U. (2020). Lubricant compatibility of FKM seals in synthetic oils. Industrial Lubrication and Tribology, 72(5), 557–565. https://doi.org/10.1108/ILT-02-2019-0065
- Canter, N. (2020, March). Metalworking fluids: Minimizing aluminum staining. Tribology & Lubrication Technology. https://www.stle.org/files/TLTArchives/2020/03_March/Feature.aspx
- Cheng, C., Phipps, D., & Alkhaddar, R. M. (2005). Treatment of spent metalworking fluids. Water Research, 39, 4051–4063. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.watres.2005.07.012
- Faulkner. (1985). Environmental stress cracking of polycarbonate and a polycarbonate/acrylic blend by windshield washer fluids (SAE Technical Paper 851628). SAE International. https://saemobilus.sae.org/content/851628
- Fitch, J. (n.d.). Recognizing the symptoms of lubricant incompatibility. Machinery Lubrication. Noria Corporation. https://www.machinerylubrication.com/Articles/Print/911
- Hatayama, H. K., Chen, J. J., de Vera, E. R., Stephens, R. D., & Storm, D. L. (1980). A method for determining the compatibility of hazardous wastes (EPA-600/2-80-076). U.S. Environmental Protection Agency. https://www.epa.gov/hwpermitting/method-determining-compatibility-hazardous-wastes
- International Organization for Standardization [ISO]. (2024). ISO 7745:2024, Hydraulic fluid power — Fire-resistant fluids — Requirements and guidelines for use. https://www.iso.org/standard/84811.html
- National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health [NIOSH]. (1998). Criteria for a recommended standard: Occupational exposure to metalworking fluids (DHHS [NIOSH] Publication No. 98-102). https://www.cdc.gov/niosh/docs/98-102/
- Occupational Safety and Health Administration [OSHA]. (n.d.). Metalworking fluids: Safety and health best practices manual. U.S. Department of Labor. https://www.osha.gov/metalworking-fluids/manual
- Samman, N. (n.d.). A review of grease compatibility. Society of Tribologists and Lubrication Engineers [STLE], Lubrication Fundamentals. https://www.stle.org/Shared_Content/End_Users/Lube_Fundamentals/Grease_Articles_FULL/A_Review_of_Grease_Compatibility.aspx
- Schoff, C. K. (2016, April). Automotive coating application defects. CoatingsTech. American Coatings Association. https://www.paint.org/wp-content/uploads/2021/09/Automotive-Coatings-Application-Defects_Apr-2016.pdf