KALTEC

BlogApplication notes

Why does rust preventive cause problems before heat treatment or plating?

Type
Application notes
Published
20 November 2026
Prepared by
Technical team
Product group
Corrosion Prevention

It is easy to assume the usual wash takes rust preventive off, but the film is made to repel water and cling to metal. What actually causes the trouble can be film that survives degreasing, residue that blocks pickling, residue burnt on in the furnace, film that keeps nitrogen and carbon out, or soil left by the wash and rinse, and two of these can act together.

Sometimes a lot of nitrided shafts shows hardness that varies from spot to spot, plated brackets peel where they are bent at assembly, or parts come out of the furnace with brown stains spread across them. These look like three unrelated defects, but traced upstream they can meet at the rust preventive applied against rust in storage. A film made to cling to the metal becomes, at the next step, soil that has to come off.

The loss usually shows only after the process is done. Peeled plating has to be stripped and redone, an uneven case shortens part life, and a defect found after shipment leaves several companies tracing the cause together. Splitting the process chain across companies makes it worse: heat treaters often receive parts without knowing what they went through upstream, and so do not know how to clean them (Blum et al., 2015).

Rust preventive is usually oil or wax carrying rust inhibitors. The inhibitor molecule sticks to the metal by its polar end, where electric charge is lopsided, and turns its oil-loving end outward to keep water and oxygen off the metal (Revie & Uhlig, 2008). The humidity cabinet test, which rates rust protection, measures how long that film holds in damp air (ASTM International, 2022b). Plating and heat treatment run straight into these properties. The cleanliness needed before electroplating is higher than for most other finishes (ASTM International, 2025), and a deposit bonds only when its atoms meet the metal with nothing in between (Kanani, 2004; Schlesinger & Paunovic, 2010). Nitriding and carburising also need nitrogen and carbon to react at the surface and diffuse inward, so a film left on the surface becomes a barrier (Blum et al., 2015; Guillot et al., 2017).

In such cases the technical team sets up the five hypotheses below and rules them out one by one. The start is always the same: find out from the upstream step which rust preventive went on, when and how heavily, and run a water-break test on parts straight out of the wash. The test dips the part in clean water and watches whether the water stays on the whole surface as an unbroken film (ASTM International, 2021).

Hypothesis 1: unremoved preservative

Suspect this one first for parts coated with wax-type or long-term preservatives, parts sprayed with a solvent-cutback product that left a waxy film once the solvent evaporated, and parts held a long time for export or as stock. It applies most when the wash line is set for the light oil that usually arrives and only the preservative has changed. Imagine shafts whose shipment is delayed, so that while they wait in the warehouse the upstream shop coats them with a long-term wax-type preservative instead of the usual light oil. They pass through the same alkaline wash as always and go into the nitriding furnace looking clean.

The usual wash struggles with this film because of how alkaline cleaners lift oil. Animal and vegetable fats react with alkali to form water-soluble soap, a reaction called saponification. Mineral oil and wax do not change chemically, so surfactants, soap-like molecules, have to wrap them and carry them into the water; that is emulsification (Durkee, 2006). Most rust-preventive base oils are mineral oil or wax, so they barely saponify and rely on emulsification alone.

Emulsification depends heavily on temperature, time and mechanical action such as spray, so the thicker and stickier the film, and the less the wax melts at bath temperature, the less it loosens. The inhibitor is also adsorbed on the metal surface (Revie & Uhlig, 2008), so a thin layer can stay after the oil is gone. The result depends on the soil, the cleaner, temperature and time, spray force and equipment design, and when the preservative is switched to a long-term one while cleaning stays set for the usual delivery state, the leftover preservative is reported to upset the nitriding result (Blum et al., 2015).

Run the water-break test first, dipping the cleaned part in clean water and lifting it out. Water that stays as an unbroken film over the whole surface means no water-repelling film; water that splits or beads means film remains. The test can detect organic soil a few molecular layers thick, but it only separates pass from fail and loses sensitivity on rough surfaces (ASTM International, 2021). For a number, measure the water contact angle. More oil gives a larger angle, but the angle alone does not prove a surface is free of soil (Becker et al., 2016; Williams & O'Bryon, 2013). A wax-type film can also be felt as a smear when scratched with a fingernail.

If the film survived degreasing, pass on information before changing the wash. Tell the next step which type of preservative went on and when, and agree on the soil and the cleaning method with the customer and the cleaner supplier (Blum et al., 2015). For wax-type or heavy films, put a precleaning stage before the alkaline clean to remove most of the film (ASTM International, 2025); hydrocarbon solvents, which dissolve oils, greases and waxes well, are candidates for it (Blum et al., 2015). Choose the lightest preservative that fits the storage time and conditions by comparing candidates in the humidity cabinet test (ASTM International, 2022b), and whenever the preservative changes, retest the wash on coupons coated with the new product and confirm a water-break pass before production (ASTM International, 2021; Blum et al., 2015).

Hypothesis 2: blocked pickling

On a plating line, look at this hypothesis for low-carbon steel parts that arrive oiled and parts whose wash was taken lightly because no oil marks showed. The failure may appear after bending or heating rather than straight after plating, so the cause is easy to miss. Picture zinc-plated brackets that passed inspection fully covered, then flake like scales the moment they are bent on the assembly line. Turn a peeled flake over and its underside looks dull.

Plating pretreatment follows a fixed order for a reason. Low-carbon steel is first stripped of oil and grease, then pickled, dissolving rust and oxide in acid, and finally cleared of smut and activated to bare metal the deposit can bond to at once (ASTM International, 2022a). Pickling acid does not dissolve oil, so where an oil film remains the acid cannot reach the metal and the oxide underneath stays too.

Plating is metal ions taking electrons at the surface and building up as atoms, and over oil or oxide the deposit cannot bond directly to the metal (Kanani, 2004; Schlesinger & Paunovic, 2010). A wide film leaves bare spots where nothing plates. A thin, patchy film lets the deposit cover but bond weakly, so it blisters or peels later. Rust inhibitors are molecules made to stick to metal (Revie & Uhlig, 2008), so they can cause this weak bond even when no oil is visible.

Lifted plating tells you where the film stayed. Record bare spots, blotchy brightness, and blisters or peeling after bending or heating, and check adhesion with qualitative tests such as bend, file, knife and heat-quench. Choose a bend test if the part will be formed later and a heat-quench test if it will be heated, and test again after any post-plating bake or heat treatment (ASTM International, 2023). Look at the underside of the peeled deposit for oil marks or oxide colour, and on the pretreatment line run a water-break test after degreasing and again after pickling to find which stage leaves the film (ASTM International, 2021).

The remedy is to put pretreatment back in the standard order. Keep to preclean, alkaline clean, electroclean, rinse, pickle, rinse, and never count on the pickle to take the oil off as well (ASTM International, 2022a, 2025). Electrocleaning passes current through the part so that gas bubbles forming at the surface lift the last of the film. Agree with the upstream step that parts going straight to plating arrive under a light, short-term preservative rather than a long-term one.

Hypothesis 3: burnt-on residue

This hypothesis comes up for parts going into protective-atmosphere or vacuum furnaces, parts with many holes and threads where oil pools, and parts dried in the basket after washing so that water gathers in one place. Parts hardened and tempered before nitriding belong here too. Think of gears washed, dried in their basket and loaded into a protective-atmosphere furnace, which come out with brown and black stains spread around the holes and wherever one gear touched another.

The organic part of a rust preventive evaporates or breaks down at heat-treating temperatures. In a protective atmosphere, the gas filled into a furnace to stop oxidation, or in a vacuum, there is too little oxygen to burn it all away, so it stays as carbon and leaves soot or brown and black stains. Experiments show that such carbon deposits inhibit nitriding much as oil contamination does (Guillot et al., 2017).

Harder still is what does not burn away. Inorganic salts from cleaners and metals such as calcium in rust inhibitors do not evaporate at temperature and stay behind like ash. Residue that sees high temperature can bake on into a very stable thin film that blocks reaction, a passive layer, and residue burnt in like this is hard to remove even by cleaning. Residue from oil burnt on during an earlier heat treatment, such as hardening and tempering before nitriding, causes the same problem (Blum et al., 2015).

The shape and place of the stains are the first clue. Stains gathered where oil pooled, at contact points between parts or inside holes, point to leftover oil; stains shaped like drips or droplets point first to residue from drying after the wash. Run a water-break test on parts just before loading to see whether an organic film remains (ASTM International, 2021), and in a vacuum furnace also log whether the vacuum recovers more slowly than usual during heat-up, which can signal a lot of volatile residue.

Burnt-in residue is hard to remove, so the measures belong before the furnace. Clean between upstream operations as well, so residue is not worked into the surface by later machining and heat, and check rinse-water contamination and drying conditions, fixing the rinse first if the stains look like drying marks (Blum et al., 2015). Make a water-break pass the entry criterion for heat treatment and reclean any part that fails (ASTM International, 2021; Blum et al., 2015).

Hypothesis 4: masked diffusion

Consider this hypothesis in treatments that put nitrogen or carbon into the surface, such as gas nitriding, nitrocarburising and carbonitriding, and above all for parts with deep holes and threads or for tightly packed loads. Its symptom shows in hardness rather than in stains. Shafts with threads and deep holes are packed into a basket and gas nitrided, and when hardness is measured, readings differ from spot to spot even within one shaft.

Gas nitriding hardens steel by adding nitrogen to the surface from ammonia gas. Ammonia breaks down at the steel surface and releases nitrogen, which sticks to the surface and then spreads inward to form a hard case. The breakdown needs a clean steel surface to act as a catalyst, a site that speeds the reaction, so oil or carbon covering it keeps nitrogen out. In experiments both machining-oil contamination and carbon deposits inhibited nitriding, and samples given multi-stage chemical washing grew the compound layer, the nitride layer at the surface, faster and more evenly (Guillot et al., 2017).

Films do not remain evenly, so the effect varies from place to place. Less nitrogen or carbon enters where film remains, leaving soft spots. In carbonitriding, which adds carbon and nitrogen together, cleaner residue and prior oxidation also changed the structure of the case, as seen by metallography, polishing a cross-section and viewing it under a microscope (Schmitt-Thomas et al., 1980). A working guide from the nitriding committee lists preservatives, waxes and greases among the soils to remove before nitriding (Blum et al., 2015).

Begin by measuring hardness at several points rather than one. Where a soft spot turns up, section it and compare the depth of the compound layer and of the diffusion zone, the nitrogen-rich layer beneath it, with a hard spot. If soft spots gather where the wash reaches poorly, such as in holes, threads and contact faces, residual film is a fair candidate for the cause.

Where residual film seems to have kept the gas out, monitor the wash as strictly as the furnace and define its test steps in advance, and when the soil is a preservative, compare cleaners and conditions on coupons coated with that product before choosing. Spray cleaning does not reach densely packed parts, so consider immersion cleaning or more space between parts as well (Blum et al., 2015).

Hypothesis 5: wash and rinse faults

Give this hypothesis more weight on shared wash lines that take many heavily preserved parts, in baths topped up for a long time without a change, and on lines with a single rinse stage or rinse water changed seldom. One example is a wash line where stains and lifting fall off in the week the bath is changed, then creep back day by day. An oil slick floats on the bath, and foam rises in the rinse tank.

A cleaning solution does not discard the oil it removes; it holds on to it. As heavily coated parts keep coming, oil builds up in the bath, and once the surfactants can take no more, cleaning power drops. Immersion cleaning needs a cleaner that releases oil quickly and oil separation that works, and in flood cleaning the oil must be separated before draining, or floating oil coats the parts again (Blum et al., 2015).

There is a problem in the opposite direction too. Alkaline cleaners contain inorganic salts and surfactants, and these stay on the surface when rinsing falls short. A case has been reported where poor rinsing and drying concentrated cleaner residue in one place and blocked nitriding (Blum et al., 2015), and on a plating line leftover alkali is carried into the next pickle tank.

When the bath is under suspicion, set the defect log beside the dates of bath changes. If defects drop just after a change and climb over time, log the oil layer on the bath, falling alkalinity, which is the strength of the cleaning chemistry, and foam and cloudiness in the rinse water. Washing the same parts in fresh and in used solution and comparing water-break results shows quickly whether the bath is the cause (ASTM International, 2021).

First, keep oil from building up in the bath. Run a skimmer or oil separator, and measure cleaner strength and oil content on a schedule to set when the bath is changed (Blum et al., 2015; Durkee, 2006). Rinse in two or more stages with clean water in the last one, and watch water quality too, since it affects the result (Blum et al., 2015). Applying less rust preventive upstream lightens the load on the bath straight away.

Testing the hypotheses

Five hypotheses do not need five investigations at once. Rule them out one at a time, starting with what is easy to ask and easy to measure. The first step is the preservative history: get from the upstream step whether it is oil, wax-type or solvent-cutback, when it went on and whether it has changed lately (Blum et al., 2015).

Next comes the water-break test straight after cleaning. If the water breaks, film remains, so look at hypothesis 1, film that survived degreasing, or hypothesis 5, the bath. If the water holds and defects still appear, turn from film to oxide, rinsing and drying (ASTM International, 2021).

A control test separates hypotheses 1 and 5. Wash the same parts in fresh and in used solution: a pass only in fresh solution points to bath control, hypothesis 5, while a fail in both means the cleaning conditions do not suit the preservative, hypothesis 1.

The shape of the defect points to the remaining hypotheses. Defects gathered in holes, threads and contact faces mean the wash is not reaching; droplet shapes mean rinsing and drying. For plating, adhesion tests and the underside of the peeled deposit show whether the film survived degreasing or pickling, which confirms hypothesis 2 (ASTM International, 2023). For heat treatment, stains alone suggest hypothesis 3 and soft spots as well suggest hypothesis 4, to be confirmed by metallography (Guillot et al., 2017; Schmitt-Thomas et al., 1980).

The last check after a fix is the result over several lots. It is done only when the water-break test keeps passing straight after cleaning and, for plating, adhesion tests pass, or, for heat treatment, hardness comes out even across several points.

The hypotheses can also overlap. A tough preservative loads the bath with oil, and the film left behind then burns in the furnace and blocks nitriding as well, so hypotheses 1 and 5, and 3 and 4, appear together. In that case fix the step furthest upstream first. Getting the type and amount of preservative right reduces several downstream hypotheses at once.

Limits and cautions

Plating defects also come from bath chemistry, current conditions, and the carbon content and surface of the steel; heat-treating defects also come from atmosphere control and temperature uniformity in the furnace. If defects persist after the cleaning is fixed, check those process variables with the plater or heat treater. High-carbon steel needs different pretreatment from low-carbon steel and follows its own guide (ASTM International, 2022a).

Mind safety as well. Alkaline cleaners contain strong bases, and sodium hydroxide harms the eyes, skin and airways. The recommended exposure limit from NIOSH in the US is a ceiling of 2 mg/m³ (NIOSH, n.d.). Mist from hot cleaning baths and the vapour and flammability of solvent precleans are hazards too. Read the safety data sheet, the SDS, of each product before changing or mixing cleaners and preservatives, and use goggles, chemical-resistant gloves and local exhaust. Changes to cleaning conditions or preservatives need verified results, so plan the trials with the supplier before making them.

Sources

  1. ASTM International. (2021). ASTM F22-21, Standard test method for hydrophobic surface films by the water-break test. https://store.astm.org/f0022-21.html
  2. ASTM International. (2022a). ASTM B183-18(2022), Standard practice for preparation of low-carbon steel for electroplating. https://store.astm.org/b0183-18r22.html
  3. ASTM International. (2022b). ASTM D1748-22, Standard test method for rust protection by metal preservatives in the humidity cabinet. https://store.astm.org/d1748-22.html
  4. ASTM International. (2023). ASTM B571-23, Standard practice for qualitative adhesion testing of metallic coatings. https://store.astm.org/b0571-23.html
  5. ASTM International. (2025). ASTM B322-99(2025), Standard guide for cleaning metals prior to electroplating. https://store.astm.org/b0322-99r25.html
  6. Becker, Merz, Hasse, & Kopnarski. (2016). Solvent cleaning and wettability of technical steel and titanium surfaces. Adsorption Science & Technology, 34(4–5), 261–274. https://doi.org/10.1177/0263617416645110
  7. Blum, T., Braun, R., Chaban, M., Huchel, U., & Klümper-Westkamp, H. (2015). Vermeidung von Sperrschichten auf zu nitrierenden Bauteilen – eine Anleitung zum Handeln. AWT Fachausschuss Nitrieren und Nitrocarburieren. https://www.awt-online.org/awt-wAssets/docs/Fachausschuesse/Vermeidung_v_Sperrschichten_a_zu_nitrierenden_Bauteilen_01.pdf
  8. Durkee, J. B. (2006). Management of industrial cleaning technology and processes. Elsevier.
  9. Guillot, B., Jégou, S., & Barrallier, L. (2017). Degradation of gaseous nitriding of steel by lubricant contamination: Effect of in-situ pre-treatments. Surface and Coatings Technology, 316, 59–70. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.surfcoat.2017.01.107
  10. Kanani, N. (2004). Electroplating: Basic principles, processes and practice. Elsevier.
  11. National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health [NIOSH]. (n.d.). NIOSH pocket guide to chemical hazards: Sodium hydroxide. CDC. https://www.cdc.gov/niosh/npg/npgd0565.html
  12. Revie, R. W., & Uhlig, H. H. (2008). Corrosion and corrosion control: An introduction to corrosion science and engineering (4th ed.). Wiley. https://doi.org/10.1002/9780470277270
  13. Schlesinger, M., & Paunovic, M. (Eds.). (2010). Modern electroplating (5th ed.). Wiley. https://doi.org/10.1002/9780470602638
  14. Schmitt-Thomas, K. G., Meisel, H., & Schreiner, A. (1980). Effect of production-related residues on the diffusion process during thermochemical heat treatments in the case of carbonitriding. Härterei-Technische Mitteilungen, 35(1), 17–23. https://portal.fis.tum.de/en/publications/effect-of-production-related-residues-on-the-diffusion-process-du/
  15. Williams, D. L., & O'Bryon, T. M. (2013). Cleanliness verification on large surfaces. In R. Kohli & K. L. Mittal (Eds.), Developments in surface contamination and cleaning (Vol. 6). Elsevier. https://doi.org/10.1016/B978-1-4377-7879-3.00005-4

Product and site consultation

Leave your company, site and the product groups in use. Our engineer will get in touch to go through your site conditions and concerns. Materials, equipment, operating conditions and downstream steps show what should change and what can stay. If nothing needs to change, we will say so.

Contact us
After you contact us
  1. 01
    Site setup

    We confirm process conditions and needs first.

  2. 02
    Spec design

    We set the product spec and selection criteria.

  3. 03
    Comparison

    We compare matching candidates and propose.

  4. 04
    Tailored supply

    We supply on time and manage the stock.

  5. 05
    Site check

    We visit, check conditions of use and record.

  6. 06
    Use management

    We track use and change cycles to catch issues.

  7. 07
    Regular analysis

    We analyze the records and send a yearly report.